Showing posts with label Indian Army Chief News. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indian Army Chief News. Show all posts

Sunday, 6 May 2012

Dedicated Communication Satellites For Indian Navy, Air Force

By Jay Menon jaymenon68@gmail.com

Source: AWIN First




India plans to launch dedicated communication satellites for the Navy and Air Force between 2012 and 2014, Defense Minister A.K. Antony says.

The naval satellite is planned to be launched in 2012-13, while the air force communication satellite is planned to be launched in 2013-14, Antony said in a written reply to a question in parliament on April 30.

He also says that the tri-services defense communication network (DCN) is progressing as per India’s defense procurement procedures.

The DCN is envisioned as a network of fiber-optic cables, satellite, Earth stations and transportable and portable satellite terminals with strong security features.

The designs for these systems have features that enable the conduct of simultaneous, real-time networked operations from multiple sites to cater to contingencies and failures, as well as hardware redundancies for failsafe operations.

Tuesday, 24 April 2012

Apex court dismisses plea against Army chief-designate

http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/industry-and-economy/article3345300.ece?homepage=true


New Delhi, April 23: 

The Supreme Court on Monday rejected a petition challenging the appointment of Lt Gen Bikram Singh as the next Army chief.

The court said that after carefully going through the averments made in the petition and the material placed before it, it does not find anything material to entertain the petition.

The court had gone through the documents submitted before it by the Centre regarding the appointment of Lt Gen Bikram Singh as the Army Chief-designate.

The PIL, filed by petitioners including former Naval Chief Admiral L. Ramdas, had challenged the appointment of Lt Gen Bikram Singh as the next Army Chief alleging his involvement in a fake encounter in 2001 in Kashmir.

The petitioners also alleged that Lt Gen Bikram Singh did not take action against certain officers accused of sexual harassment when he was leading a peacekeeping force in Congo. The petitioners warned that these charges should not be ignored as they are serious in nature, adding that Lt Gen Bikram Singh was promoted not entirely on grounds of merit.

The court sought to know whether the charges against Lt Gen Bikram Singh were forwarded to the Cabinet Committee on Appointments when the green signal was given for him to succeed Gen V.K. Singh as the next Army Chief when the latter retires on May 31.

The Government had claimed that the PIL was filed with malafide intention and with an intention to rake up the controversy of the Army Chief's age once again.

It maintained that Lt Gen Bikram Singh's appointment was done in a transparent manner, adding that there was a communal angle to the case.

The apex court restrained the petitioners from coming up with “bald” allegations against Lt Gen Bikram Singh.

The court, while agreeing to hear the PIL against Lt Gen Bikram Singh's appointment as the Army Chief-designate, however, said it will not re-consider the age controversy of the Army Chief Gen V K Singh.
The court had earlier declined to conduct the proceedings in the matter ‘in-camera’ (in private).

Monday, 23 April 2012

Supreme Court seeks Army Chief designate's file

New Delhi,


The Supreme Court on Monday directed the Centre to place before it the file pertaining to the appointment of Lt. Gen. Bikram Singh as the next Army Chief.

A bench of justices R.M. Lodha and H.L. Gokhale decided to go through the confidential document while hearing a PIL challenging the appointment of Bikram Singh and asked the government to place the file before it at 2 p.m.

The bench refused to hold an ‘in-camera’ proceeding in the case as pleaded by the petitioners, who alleged that it’s a sensitive issue, which should not be discussed in the open court.

The bench turned down the petitioners’ plea, saying all the allegations levelled in the petition have already become well-known through media reports.

The bench was hearing a PIL filed by retired officers and bureaucrats, including former Naval Chief Admiral Laxminarayan Ramdas and former Chief Election Commissioner N. Gopalaswamy, challenging the appointment of Bikram Singh as the next Army Chief.

At the outset of the proceeding, when the petitioners referred to the age row of the current Army Chief, the bench made it clear that it would not go into that controversy again as it has been settled by the apex court earlier.

The Centre, represented by its top lawyers, including Attorney General G.E. Vahanvati and Solicitor General Rohinton F. Nariman, vociferously opposed the PIL saying it has been filed with malafide intention and to rake up the age controversy again.

The government objected to the contentions made in the petition on the ground that it has tried to bring communal angle in the case by alleging that Sikh groups tried to lobby for Bikram Singh.
The apex court also wanted to know from the Centre if the allegations made against Bikram Singh in an alleged fake encounter case in Jammu and Kashmir and his questionable role during U.N. peacekeeping mission in Congo were placed before the Cabinet Committee on Appointments.
Lt General Singh, currently heading the Army’s Eastern Command, is to succeed General V K Singh who demits office on May 31.
Challenging the appointment, the petitioners, had alleged in their PIL that Lt General Singh was involved in a fake encounter case in Jammu and Kashmir in 2001 and the case is pending in the high court there.
The petitioners, also including veteran journalist Sam Rajapa and social activist M.G. Devasahayam, alleged that Lt. Gen. Singh failed to take action against officers who were involved in sexual harassment and rape, when they were posted to Congo in 2008 as part of the U.N. peace-keeping mission.
The government had on March 3 announced the appointment of Lt. Gen. Bikram Singh as the next Army chief.

Army Chief hints at One Rank One Pension

Press Trust of India | Updated: April 23, 2012 09:56 IST



Ballia (Bihar):  The Chief of Army Staff (COAS), General V K Singh, has hinted at implementation of One Rank One Pension and said all information regarding ex-armymen would be collected and their problems would be sorted out.

Addressing a conference of ex-armymen yesterday, General Singh said that all efforts were being made to implement One Rank One Pension from the last two years.

Stating efforts were also being made to remove disparity in the family pension scheme, the Army Chief said it may take time, but there would certainly be one or the other good outcome.


The implementation of One Rank One Pension would involve an expenditure of Rs. 3,000 crore, but it was less from the point of the welfare of the soldiers, General Singh said.

He was in Ballia to unveil the statue of former Prime Minister Chadrashekhar at Devsthali.

Assuring soldiers after becoming pensioners they would not be forgotten, General Singh said both unit and headquarters have been directed to speedily redress pension related and other complaints of ex-armymen.

He said that all details of ex-armymen, including that of their families, were being gathered and they would include whether any family member of an ex-armyman was aggrieved and what his problem was.

Though the media was kept away from his programme, some reporters managed to enter the venue and enquired General Singh whether he would hand over documents related to the bribery case to the CBI.

The Army Chief refused to comment and said that media should gather information from the CBI in this regard.

At a public function later, General Singh emphasised on setting up of better educational institutions in rural areas and said they should focus on all round development of students.

"It is the responsibility of the younger generation to take the country forward," he added.

Chandrashekhar's son and MP Neeraj Shekhar and MLC Ravishanker Pappu were also present at the event.

Thursday, 12 April 2012

A battle without winners






The row over General V.K. Singh's age has created fissures between the Army and the Ministry of Defence. The main victim is the modernisation of the Army.
Irrespective of the outcome of the Mexican stand-off between General V.K. Singh and the Ministry of Defence (MoD) over his disputed date of birth, both the Army and the Defence Ministry are eventually bound to be the losers in equal measure.
Sadly, Gen. Singh's tenure, whenever he retires will be known principally for his age dispute, attendant subterfuges by his predecessors to allegedly ensure their favoured candidates' succession to the Army's top job and the MoD's disingenuous role in what was seemingly an avoidable hullabaloo.
The battle over “reconciling” the commander-in-chief's birth date will also go down, without prejudice to either of the two disputants, as possibly the most bizarre challenge ever faced by any modern military, leave alone the world's third largest army.
But closure in the matter, in a largely graceless and unforgiving system, will almost certainly engender grief and bitterness in varying measure for the feuding parties where such eventual outcomes are rarely, if at all, handled with either goodwill or magnanimity.
Consider the Hobbesian options:
If Gen. Singh's honour is vindicated by the Supreme Court, backroom negotiations or both, the Army despite avowals to the contrary, would consider it a long overdue slap to the overbearing MoD.
Conceding 1951 to be Gen Singh's birth year would also unquestioningly reinforce the chief's right to serve an additional 10 months in office till March 2013 in order to complete the legitimate tenure to which the solider, much lauded in recent weeks by the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) administration, was appointed in March 2010. This would also make him eligible for all “attendant benefits” including pay and emoluments as Gen. Singh has demanded in his Supreme Court petition.
However, retiring Gen. Singh in May 2010 following a “deal” or a “compromise” on vindicating his honour though well within the government's purview, would effectively make Service rules infractuous, rendering even critical military tenures negotiable entities by vested political interests.
This recalls the equally significant, but highly questionable appointment of Sanjeev Tripathi as the Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) chief on December 30, 2010 — the day he was superannuating having attained the age of 60 — after the incumbent K.C. Verma “voluntarily” advanced his retirement date by one month, enabling his junior to succeed him and secure an additional two years in office.
Mr. Verma was reportedly “advised” by the UPA that “offering” to step down as RAW chief 30 days earlier, thereby facilitating Mr. Tripathi's ascension, would make him eligible to head the signals intelligence gathering agency, the National Technical Research Organisation. Thirteen months later, Mr. Verma is still awaiting that appointment.
Conversely, if the MoD prevails over the Army chief, its bureaucrats will chalk it up as yet another, albeit belaboured, victory in their endless rounds of put-me-downs of the uniforms which, in the larger sense really epitomises the Singh-MoD controversy.

Has led to split

The dispute has also created avoidable fault lines within the Services, with many officers supporting the Chief and others believing him to be driven by personal ambition.
Either way, the losing side — whether that's the Army or the MoD, irrespective of the ongoing frenetic negotiations seeking an equitable resolution — will sulk and opportunity presenting, is sure to strike back. In short, widening fissures between Army headquarters and the MoD, simmering for decades and now having reached boiling point, will take long to be salved irrespective of the placatory noises from both sides.

Issue of modernisation

Consequently, Gen. Singh's successor will, doubtless, be more preoccupied with mending these ruptures rather than getting on with the urgent brief of modernising the Army's matériel that desperately needs rejuvenating to enable it operate in a turbulent, militarily sophisticated and increasingly nuclearised neighbourhood.
The age controversy, which has been rumbling ever since Gen. Singh took over and reached a critical stage in May 2011, has already stymied the Army's long-delayed modernisation with little or nothing having being achieved in this field over the past two years, compared with the frantic activity in the two other Services.
A mid-2011 report by the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) and global financial consultants KPMG, for instance revealed that since 2007, India had confirmed over $25 billion worth of military purchases of which the Indian Air Force's share was $17.46 billion, the Indian Navy's $6.16 billion, the Indian Coast Guard's $616 million and the Indian Army's a mere $420 million.
It remains an open secret that the equipment profile of the army's combat arms — infantry and armour — remains woefully inadequate whilst that of support arms like artillery, air defence and the Army Aviation Corps (AAC) to name a few, is equally deficient and obsolete.
By the Army's own admittance, a large proportion of its Main Battle Tank T72M1 “Ajeya” fleet is night blind as is the AAC, both of which constitute a crucial ingredient of the controversial “cold start” doctrine of launching a pre-emptive offensive against Pakistan in a limited war scenario to achieve negotiable military gains in a nuclear weapons environment.
The scandalous artillery deficiency is plagued by an endless cycle of tenders issued, withdrawn and re-issued and several rounds of inconclusive trials conducted, all further complicated by the MoD totally or conditionally blacklisting several top howitzer vendors without providing clarity on their respective status.
More worryingly, some 359 infantry battalions trained ironically for nuclear warfare await the import of a basic weapon system: the 5.56mm assault rifle (AR) to replace the inefficient, locally designed but costly, Indian Small Arms System (INSAS) AR which the army has tentatively employed since the mid-1990's and now abandoned after massive investments.
A tender for 66,000 ARs was issued to 43 overseas vendors last November. Given the Army's and the MoD's cumbersome field trials, evaluation and price negotiation procedures, a winner is not likely to emerge for at least two years if not longer.
Alongside, the army's Fast Track Procurement route to acquire equipment for operational readiness with a 12-14 month timeline rarely ever meets that target, taking twice if not three times as long to execute.
And while Gen. Singh could not have even partially made good these deferred matériel shortcomings during his tenure, the institutional antagonism his birth date has generated is undeniably a reason that the Army's overdue modernisation drive has had to be postponed, something that will eventually have an impact on the country's defence posture. Is setting the record straight on his age the price worth paying?
(Rahul Bedi is India correspondent for Jane's Defence Weekly and is based in New Delhi.)

Army Chief knew of ‘spooked’ story in March

Kathmandu, http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article3283571.ece

Army chief General V K Singh has termed a newspaper report on the movement of two army units in January ‘spooking the government’ as ‘absolutely stupid’. He made the remark on Thursday in response to a question about the story -- which had appeared in The Indian Express on Wednesday -- during a visit to Nepal where he is attending a regional seminar on disaster management and humanitarian assistance.

The chief’s remarks came on a day when his host country’s Prime Minister, Baburam Bhattarai, hailed the role of the Indian Army and its values in an official bilateral meeting.
Dr. Bhattarai’s press advisor, Ram Rijhan Yadav, told The Hindu that when General Singh mentioned that the Indian Army operates according to ‘democratic values and principles’, the Nepal PM said that the Nepal Army (NA) too operated according to the same values. Dr Bhattarai, who is a senio leader of Maoists in Nepal, also acknowledged the training and exposure received by Nepal Army officers in India, and said this had helped the NA transition from a force controlled by the monarchy to being one under an elected government.

‘Nefarious aims’
Meanwhile, a new dimension to the troop deployment controversy emerged with The Week magazine releasing the audio recording of an interview it conducted with General Singh in early March, -- excerpts of which were published in the magazine on March 13 -- in which the Army chief expressed his apprehension that the normal movement of soldiers could be presented in a distorted way. “Even, let us say one of our corps or divisions or brigades exercise, somebody will say, oh! They did an exercise. It was not an exercise; they wanted to do something else," he is heard saying. “Now you will make a story out of it. There are lots of people who want to make stories these days for various nefarious aims, if I can put it like that.”

According to PTI, he had pointed to ‘people both uniformed and not in uniform, some civil servants, who had their own axis to grind…feeding all kinds of wrong things’. General Singh added, “So, you tell him (the journalist) something juicy, it comes on front page and nobody even looks whether there is any truth in it. It is already done. So, you have already thrown muck on somebody. There are lots of people who are doing that and I don't know what their motives are.”
Besides the Prime Minister Bhattari, General Singh met Nepal’s president, Ram Baran Yadav, deputy PM and defence minister Bijay Kumar Gachhedar, his counterpart, Nepal Army chief General Chhatraman Singh Gurung and other serving and retired army officers. Through his visit, his refrain, speaking in Nepali, was, ‘Whatever is good for Nepal is good for India.” General Singh also offered any assistance – training, weapons, and ammunition – that the Nepal government needed and sought.

Wednesday, 11 April 2012

China, India and the lesson of Megara's burning pigs


http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/article3277920.ece

General V.K. Singh's leaked letter on deficits in India's defence has fostered hysteria. Fearsome as China's military build-up might be, it isn't clear why Indians should be fearful.
In 266 BCE, the armies of Emperor Antigonus II Gonatas laid siege to Megara, hoping to seize the small, but wealthy, city's harbours. The contest was, at first glance, hopeless: Antigonus's armies were much larger and backed, moreover, by phalanxes of battle-elephants.
Faced with certain defeat — the ancient military historian Poluainos recorded in his classic, Strategems in War — the Megarans hit upon a tactic of considerable genius. The city's pigs were doused in resin and set on fire as they were pushed out of the gates. Panicked by the sight of the burning, squealing pigs, the elephants broke ranks and fled, trampling many of Antigonus' army.
Indians panicked by Army Chief V.K. Singh's grim warnings on system-wide deficits in the country's war-preparedness might profit from the lesson of Megara's burning pigs: in war, the side with the bigger guns doesn't always win. The anxiety underpinning much of the debate provoked by General Singh's leaked letter to the Prime Minister isn't hard to miss. The rise of an allegedly-malevolent China, many in India's strategic community fear, makes the prospect of a war almost inevitable: a war that Pakistan, more likely than not, will capitalise upon.
Back in 2008, Defence Minister A.K. Anthony is believed to have issued a formal directive calling on the armed forces to prepare themselves for a two-front war. Mulayam Singh Yadav, India's former Defence Minister, even told Parliament in November 2011 that he had evidence China was “going to attack us soon.” “The attack can take place any time,” he asserted.
Two reasons
The facts behind fears like these are well known. China's declared military budget for this year is $106.4 billion, up from about $91.5 billion in 2011, and in line with a more than a decade-long expansion of over 12 per cent a year, a little over the growth of its wealth. It is expanding its cruise and ballistic missile arsenal; the new Dong Feng-21D, comes with a manoeuvrable warhead that constitutes the first serious threat to United States carriers in the Pacific. It has rolled out a prototype for a fifth-generation stealth fighter and inducted an aircraft carrier.
Fearsome as China's military build-up might be, though, it isn't clear if Indians need to be fearful. India isn't, for one, China's principal threat. Eight of China's 18 Group Armies — the equivalent, roughly, of a corps — face out on its south-eastern seaboard, trained and equipped for a war over Taiwan. “Much of the observed upgrade activity,” the U.S. Department of Defence noted in a 2011 report, “has occurred in units with the potential to be involved in a Taiwan contingency.”
In the Koreas, the People Liberation Army (PLA) must consider the prospect of everything from a full-blown war involving nuclear weapons to a meltdown which could send millions of refugees across its borders. Its forces must be prepared to deal with an insurgency in Xinjiang, and potential disorder in Tibet. They must protect China's trade routes, and guard contested basins of energy in the high seas. Each of these threats could conceivably lead to a showdown with the U.S. — the world's pre-eminent power.
India's second reason not to be fearful of China's military growth is this: the threat is made up of gunpowder, but also hype. The case of China's submarine threat is instructive. Five years ago, analysts in the U.S. were predicting that the PLA Navy would outstrip their submarine holdings by 2011. But Russia, concerned about the expansion of China's naval power, held back on supplies of critical technology — and the U.S. doubled its submarine production.
Last year, the U.S. estimated that China has five nuclear-powered attack submarines, three of them 091 Han-class vessels that are reaching the end of their service lives. In addition, it has some 50 diesel submarines, half of them obsolete, and a handful of experimental ballistic-missile submarines.
The U.S. Navy, though, has 53 attack submarines, four guided-missile submarines and 14 ballistic-missile boats — 71 in all. All this not counting the fleets of its European partners, and regional allies like Japan, Korea and Australia.
Lessons of 1962
None of this, China-sceptics in India argue, is reason to be sanguine — pointing, almost always, to the war of 1962 as an example of the costs of complacency. In fact, that war is an excellent illustration of the proposition that weapons capabilities alone don't win wars. From P.B. Sinha and A.A. Athale's History of the Conflict With China, 1962, an official account commissioned by the Union Defence Ministry in 1992, we know this: “Chinese weapons, equipment organisation and training were better than that of the Indians. But this superiority was only marginal. By itself it would not have proved decisive.”
India's Air Force, notably, was actually better equipped than its Chinese adversaries — crippled because the country's rupture with the Soviet Union had left it without access to spares, and without airfields in Tibet from where its jets could carry full payloads. However, India chose not to use its superior air power — fearing, among other things, that it would open the way for retaliatory strikes.
John Galbraith, the U.S. Ambassador to New Delhi, also lobbied hard against air strikes, fearing his country, then engaged in a stand-off with the Soviet Union over the placement of nuclear missiles in Cuba, would be dragged into the war.
The then-Director of Operations at air headquarters, H.C. Dewan, argued in a 1988 interview that the use of air assets would have been of limited use, since the North-East's jungles provided infantry with cover to the attackers.
Dr. Sinha and Colonel Athale, however, disputed this proposition, noting that air strikes would have crippled China's logistics, and made the passage of its forces through mountain passes lethal going. Either way, the lesson is simple: superiority doesn't mean military victory.
Last year, in a talk delivered around the same time Mr. Yadav was holding out his prediction of imminent assault, the scholar Kanti Bajpai offered several sound military reasons why 1962 wouldn't happen again. He pointed to the difficulties in destroying India's Air Force, necessary to secure China's logistics; the robust defensive positions occupied by India's Army in the Himalayas; the limited capabilities to wage a naval campaign in the Indian Ocean; the risks of internal conflict in Tibet breaking out; and, above all, the risk of a nuclear conflagration.
Dr. Bajpai concluded by asserting that “war between the two countries is not very likely unless one or the other engages in highly provocative, ill-judged behaviour — and even then, with nuclear weapons and air power, it would be very risky to go to war.”
What is to be learned
Indian diplomats have been listening, but not its military: the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute recently stated that India has become the world's largest importer of arms in 2007-2011 — playing catch-up with China, which held top position in 2002-2006. It seems unclear, though, precisely what kinds of war these acquisitions are intended to address. In 2010, former Army Chief Deepak Kapoor spoke of a two-front war. Not many weeks later, Gen. Singh suggested he saw little risk of conventional war, but insisted that India “should have a great amount of conventional capability.”
Precisely what a “great amount” might be has never been defined: in military debates, everything from all-out conventional wars to limited, localised wars in the Himalaya are discussed, often in the same breath. Indeed, it's hard to erase the suspicion that India is still preparing to fight the 1962 war again: its forces are deployed on much the same axis, and its tactical language remains unchanged.
Faced with questions, Indian military strategists often argue that armies need to prepare for possible wars, not just predictable ones. This proposition isn't as robust as it first seems. No army in the world has infinite resources — and in a volatile world, almost any war is conceivable.
Gen. Singh's letter has had the salutary impact of focussing attention on delays and corruption in defence acquisition. It has also had the wholly undesirable consequence of engendering a public culture in which any, and all, military claims for equipment are seen as legitimate.
For India to shape a serious response to the military rise of China, its intelligentsia and military establishment ought be studying China far harder. India's universities, intelligence services and military all have large shortages of staff even familiar with the language of our most important neighbour, let alone the intricacies of its strategic thinking. India may well need more hardware — but it needs to think about what hardware it needs, and how to use it to best effect like the Megarans.
India's pre-1962 military, the official history recorded, conducted “no studies of Chinese war tactics.” “No debriefing was done,” it continues, “after the Korean war to learn about their ways of working and fighting. Nobody seems to have cared to know [sic].” Few, it seems, still do.

Antony terms reports on shortage of tanks ammunition as 'rumours'

New Delhi,
http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article3299573.ece?homepage=true

Dismissing as “rumours” reports about shortage of certain tanks ammunition, Defence Minister A. K. Antony today said there will always be “shortcomings” but the country was in a much stronger position as compared to the past.
“These are all rumours. I can assure you that the country is fully prepared. India is in much more strong position as compared to the past.
There will always be some shortcomings and that is also in the process. We can’t expect 100 per cent requirements to be fulfilled and also that entire force is not on the front. They are all spread over,” he told reporters in New Delhi.
The minister was commenting on news reports suggesting that only four days of ammunition was left with the Army’s armoured regiments, on the sidelines of the two-day IAF Commanders’ Conference.
In his letter written to the Prime Minister in March, Army Chief Gen. V. K. Singh had also pointed out that armoured regiments were facing a critical shortage of ammunition.
On the issue of the decision of Parliament’s Standing Committee on Defence to call the three service chiefs to brief it about defence preparedness, Mr. Antony said, “I am not the man to decide. This decision relates to the Standing Committee”.
On the IAF conference, the Defence Minister expressed happiness over the fact that the Air Force had concluded 317 capital acquisition contracts worth over Rs. 1.11 lakh crore in the last five years.
“We are also very confident about our preparedness. Some new platforms have already started coming and more will come in the near future,” he said.

Defence Secretary says claim of troop threat unfounded

NEW DELHI, http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article3297686.ece

In briefings to MPs, government denies it panicked because of January troop movements
Defence Secretary Shashi Kant Sharma has told Parliament that troop movements around New Delhi in mid-January — movements which the government is reported to have been "spooked" by — were in fact part of a “routine drill”.
In a testimony before the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Defence, he also denied claims that the troop movements were not authorised by the government. He said there were no standard operating procedures in place for reporting exercises at the level of army corps and below — and thus, no rules were violated.
Earlier this month, The Indian Express reported that exercises by troops of the 50 Independent Para Brigade and a Hisar-based mechanised infantry formation sparked “panic” in the government. The movements took place, even as Chief of the Army Staff General V.K. Singh moved the Supreme Court, seeking an emendation to his date of birth, which would have given him several more months in office.
In an interview to The Hindu, General Singh described claims that the Army was plotting a coup as “fables of a sick mind.” The Army earlier said the movements were intended to rehearse its preparedness to move special forces and tanks to airbases in heavy fog.
Emerging facts
From background briefings provided to individual members on the Standing Committee, some new facts have begun to emerge on the events of January 15-16.
Late on the evening of January 15, the MPs were told, a senior officer serving at the Chandimandir-based Western Command notified the government of troop movements around New Delhi. The Western Command —responsible for the security along the India-Pakistan border from Abohar-Fazilka to Jammu — had learned of the troop movements from the Jaipur-based South-western Command, which controls 50 Para and the Hisar-based formation.
“The officer,” said a senior intelligence official who corroborated this account while speaking to The Hindu, “said he was merely flagging the development for the government's attention. He did not attribute motives.”
For days before this notification, however, both the Intelligence Bureau and senior politicians had worried that the fraught atmosphere created by General Singh's confrontation might lead to indiscipline.
Intelligence Bureau Director Nehchal Sandhu was, therefore, charged with investigating the officer's claims. He sought counsel, among others, from Jammu and Kashmir Governor N.N. Vohra, and India's most experienced defence bureaucrats, early on the morning of January 16. Key military commanders were also contacted.
Intelligence Bureau officials, however, denied claims that there was panic. “If someone called up the police and said there was a suicide-bomber standing outside the Prime Minister's house,” one officer said, “we'd have to take it seriously, even if the chances were slim. You can hardly expect us to have been laid back about a possible crime against the Constitution.”
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, the Standing Committee was told, was only informed of the night's events at a routine morning meeting with National Security Adviser Shivshankar Menon. Government sources insisted that this was not because the troop movement was seen as a threat, but to prepare him for any question he might face in Parliament.
Mr. Sharma himself returned to New Delhi on the afternoon of January 16 from a business visit to Malaysia. MPs have been told that he rescheduled his journey on January 15 after learning that General Singh was preparing to move the Supreme Court. He spent much of the day discussing legal issues connected to the case, before meeting the Director-General of Military Operations, Lieutenant-General Ashok Chaudhury, late that night.
The Defence Secretary, the MPs were told, asked General Chaudhury to have the troops moved out once their exercises were complete. However, two senior officials The Hindu spoke to said the exercises were immediately terminated and the troops were ordered out of their positions.

Parliamentary panel summons military chiefs

NEW DELHI,


The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Defence has summoned the chiefs of the three armed services to testify before it, an unprecedented move made after top military officials told the members that India may not be able to meet a two-front war.
The decision was made after closed-door hearings on Monday, when the committee heard testimony from the Vice-Chiefs of the Army and the Air Force, as well as Defence Ministry officials, the Defence Research and Development Organisation and public-sector defence organisations.
The service chiefs were asked to testify on April 20, the first time they will appear before Parliament's key oversight body on India's military preparedness.
Parliament's ongoing hearings come against the background of the leak of a letter from the outgoing Chief of the Army Staff, V.K. Singh, to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, warning of “hollowness” in India's military preparedness.
In 2008, Defence Minister A.K. Antony asked the armed forces to prepare themselves for a two-front war involving both Pakistan and China, but military commanders have been saying delays in procurement mean they are unprepared.
Grim warnings
Air Marshal Kishan Nowhar, sources in the committee told The Hindu, said the Air Force currently had 34 squadrons of combat aircraft, against the 45 squadrons needed to fight a two-front war. Its combat strength, he said, would fall further to 31 squadrons by 2017, as obsolete aircraft are retired. Though the Air Force's numbers would again begin to rise after that, Air Marshal Nowhar told the committee, China's Air Force would then have acquired a decisive lead.
Air Marshal Nowhar also argued, the sources said, that assumptions that the U.S. primacy in the Pacific would tie down the bulk of Chinese forces on the country's eastern seaboard could no longer be taken for granted.
Lt.-Gen. S.K. Singh, Army's Vice-Chief, focussed on shortages in war-fighting ordnance. India was down to four days of armour-penetrating shells for its tanks, he said, instead of the 40 battle-preparedness plans called for. The shortages arose because the Israeli manufacturer on whom the Army relied had been blacklisted after corruption charges.
Members of the standing committee say they intend to ask why the Army relied on a single manufacturer for critical munitions.
The committee also heard from key players in the Tatra truck scandal, which broke out after General V.K. Singh claimed to have been offered an Rs. 1.4 billion bribe to clear purchases of the vehicle.

No shortage of tank ammunition, says Antony, contradicts Army vice-chief

Reported by Sunil Prabhu | Updated: April 10, 2012 11:57 IST


New Delhi:  Defence Minister A K Antony has said that reports of the Army being short of tank ammunition are just "rumours."

The minister's statement appears to contradict the vice-chief of the Army, General SK Singh. He has told a committee of MPs in the event of a war, ammunition to take on enemy tanks, which is meant to last 40 days, would be exhausted in less than 20 days because of poor reserves.  
The vice-chief shared this with the Standing Committee on Defence yesterday.
The committee has asked to meet with the three service chiefs on April 20 to explain their troops' preparedness. Last month, a letter from Army Chief General VK Singh to the Prime Minister was leaked. It highlighted the archaic arms and ammunition that the Army is forced to work with. General Singh had written in confidence to the PM to say that air defence was "97% obsolete" and the Army's tanks are "devoid of critical ammunition to defeat enemy tanks."

The Opposition agreed that the leak of the Army Chief's letter was as worrying as its contents. The Intelligence Bureau has been assigned to identify the mole while the government has promised to explain what is being done to procure the equipment and ammunition needed for the defence forces. As a starting point, Defence Minister AK Antony has said more financial powers will be transferred to the Army.

The standing committee on defence, which is headed by Congress MP Satpal Maharaj, will meet the heads of the Army, Navy and Airforce a day after the combined commanders conference, where the country's overall defence strategy will be analysed.  

Sunday, 8 April 2012

How come the world’s largest arms importer is 97% underprepared, PM Sir?

Rajesh Kalra28 March 2012, 02:05 PM IST


The letter written by the Army chief, General V K Singh, to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on March 12 this year on the state of our defence preparedness is explosive, and shocking. The leaked letter makes a lot of points, critical among which are the following:

1. The Army’s tank fleet is “devoid of critical ammunition to defeat enemy tanks”.

2. Our air defence is “97 per cent obsolete and it doesn’t give the deemed confidence to protect”.

3. The infantry is crippled with “deficiencies and lacks night fighting” capabilities.

4. Elite special forces are “woefully short of essential weapons”.

5. There are “large-scale voids in critical surveillance” capabilities.

Anyone reading through the points raised by the general, who has been forced into an avoidable spat with the government, would know what he is hinting at. He is raising doubts over the defence procurement procedures that have crippled our defence preparedness and the larger issue of how corrupt the entire system is.

A lot has been debated since the bribery scandal erupted a few days ago, but there is one issue that is crystal clear. As was reported a few days ago, India is now the world’s largest importer of arms, displacing China and now accounts for 10 per cent of global arms sales in terms of volumes. The report by the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute says that between 2007 and 2011, India’s imports of major weapons increased by a stunning 38 per cent. The report goes on to say that India is expected to spend more than $100 billion on weapon systems over the next 15 years.

Now, does this news not rankle somewhere? Does it not conflict with what the general is saying? If we are the world’s largest importer of arms in the world, why are we so deficient in defence preparedness? There can only be two reasons.

One, we need to spend a lot more than we currently do. In fact, given the gloomy picture painted by Gen Singh with 97 per cent obsolescence in air defence preparedness, for example, perhaps we need to make it to 20 per cent of global volumes to bridge the gap.

The second reason could be that the huge amount of money (10 per cent of what the world spends on arm purchases) supposedly going in for purchasing equipment is actually finding its way elsewhere.

I leave it to your judgment and intelligence to decide which of the two is correct.

But having said that, my advice to those who are piling on to the Army chief -- some MPs have even demanded that he be sacked -- would be: Please don’t shoot the messenger. It is thanks to him that for the first time the issue of corruption in the defence forces is at least being discussed in the open. So far, it was brushed under the carpet in the garb of national security.

The common man has been getting increasingly intolerant of corruption in the government. Please understand, as soon as its impact on our security apparatus gets out in the open, we will get into an extremely perilous situation. Our MPs, whose own credibility is at its nadir currently, would do well to grab the opportunity to cleanse the system and not be seen as those who will target a general who is speaking out, simply because their own vested interests could be under threat.

Tuesday, 3 April 2012

New details emerge on Tatra truck deal

NEW DELHI,



Even as Central Bureau of Investigation detectives have begun questioning Ravi Rishi, the London-based millionaire businessman at the heart of the showdown between the Defence Ministry and Chief of the Army Staff V.K. Singh, fresh details have begun to emerge of the truck deal that precipitated the crisis.

Rajan Mukherjee, the general manager of West Bengal-based Ural India, has told The Hindu that General Singh — then General Officer-Commanding of the Eastern Command — had requested the firm to provide trucks for testing in 2008, after Tatra trucks sold by Mr. Rishi's firm “miserably failed 17 Mountain for performing Quick Reaction Team and reconnaissance duties in [the] super-high altitude areas of northern Sikkim.”

“Defects”
“During the trials,” Mr. Mukherjee said in an e-mail to The Hindu, “the Tatra vehicle developed defects in engine assembly, whereas Ural's engine performance was satisfactory even after running about 600 km at high altitude.”

Mr. Rishi owns Vectra, a conglomerate which has a controlling stake in Czech and Slovak-based specialist truck firm Tatra, which has supplied the Indian Army since 1986.

Rashi Verma, a Joint Secretary at the Defence Ministry, had said last week that the government had “never received any complaint from the armed forces” — a statement which suggests the Eastern Command either chose not to pass on its problems with the Tatra to the army headquarters in New Delhi, or that its reports were suppressed by higher authorities.

In an exclusive interview to The Hindu published on March 26, General Singh had said he was offered a Rs. 14-crore bribe, which, it emerged, was linked to an officer allegedly representing Tatra to clear a consignment of 600 trucks.

There is no information available so far if Ural India's trucks were the sole platform tested by the Eastern Command in Northern Sikkim and if so, why. Ural is co-owned by Kolkata-based magnate J.K. Saraf, who knew Gen. Singh during his tenure as Eastern Army Commander. There is no allegation, however, of the relationship having caused improper influence to be exercised.

Mr. Mukherjee's claims, however, stand in stark contrast to earlier statements by VRS Natarajan, the head of public-sector giant BEML, which co-manufactures Tatra trucks in India. Mr. Natarajan claimed that Ural India's trucks had been knocked out of competition in the ongoing trials, a claim Mr. Mukherjee has denied in his e-mail to The Hindu, adding that his firm is considering “appropriate action.”

The BEML chief, however, has since been backed by Defence Research and Development Organisation chief V.K. Saraswat, who said Tatra trucks were “outstanding.” Both BEML and Tatra have said they are considering legal action against General Singh, but provided no details of their course of action.

Army sources said the problem encountered in Sikkim could have been related to the Tatra truck's engine, which is designed for rugged battlefield use, compromising high-altitude performance in return for lower risks of breakdown.

CBI officials refused comment on the issues they had discussed with Mr. Rishi, but the businessman has been barred from leaving India until further notice.

He was earlier questioned by the agency officials last week, soon after the CBI registered an FIR in the case. CBI officials were also poring over and analysing a number of documents seized during raids in Delhi, Noida and Bangalore.

Apart from Mr. Rishi, the FIR refers to unknown officials of BEML, Vectra and the Army. The case was registered under provisions of the Indian Penal Code relating to criminal conspiracy to cheat and under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
The investigators are tasked with looking into all purchases of Tatra trucks made from 1997, when Vectra took control of Tatra. Since 1986, the Army has purchased some 7,000 Tatra trucks to transport troops and artillery.