Showing posts with label UK Defence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UK Defence. Show all posts

Tuesday, 19 June 2012

State pension will cost £146,000 per household

By James Kirkup
2:32PM BST 27 Apr 2012




Taxpayers will also have to find the equivalent of £33,000 for every household to pay for “unfunded” public sector pensions, Office for National Statistics figures showed.

The ONS published the first formal assessment of the UK’s total pension liabilities, the sums owed to current pensioners and today’s workers when they eventually retire.

Overall, those liabilities are estimated at £7.1 trillion, almost five times the value of the entire UK economy. That money will have to paid out of the lifetimes of current and future pensioners.

Only £2.1 trillion of that sum will be met by private sector employers and pension funds. The remaining £5 trillion are obligations on the Government, either through the state pension or the retirement schemes of public sector workers.

By far the biggest part of that liability is state pensions and other payments made directly to people over the state retirement age.

The Government already spends more than £100 billion a year on pension-age benefits, around one seventh of all public spending.

The sum that will increase as average life expectancy rises and people live longer in retirement. To curb the costs, the state retirement age will rise to 68 and beyond.

The ONS said the total cost of funding such commitments to current and future pensioners will be £3.8 trillion.

That is 263 per cent of GDP and almost four times current national debt. It is also equal to £146,153 for every one of the 26 million households in the UK.

The state pension is “unfunded” meaning there is not a sum of money earmarked to pay for them.

Instead, they are paid from general government revenues, meaning the £3.8 trillion will be raised from taxes and other levies on workers and companies in future years.

Using the same definition, many public sector workers’ pensions are also “unfunded”, even though employees contribute to the costs of their own retirements.

The ONS said that State employees including civil servants, teachers, National Health Service employees, the Armed Forces, police officers and firefighters have “unfunded” pensions

The total cost of funding pensions for those groups will be £852 billion, the statisticians said.

“Unfunded” pension liabilities are omitted from the national accounts, meaning the future costs identified by the ONS do not count towards the national debt.

Other public sector pensions, including those for local government staff and the BBC, are classified as “funded” schemes. But they will still put £313 billion of obligations on the State in future.

The National Association of Pension Funds said the huge figures underlined the need for Britain to save more for retirement.

Mel Duffield, head of research at the NAPF, said: “Retirement comes with a big price tag and we fear the burden on our society and our economy will only get worse.

“The core problem is that our society is not saving enough for its old age and so we will have to work longer or save more, or both. Retirement ages are rising and new rules to automatically place all workers in a pension will help, but more needs to be done.”

Steve Webb, the pensions minister, said the costs described by the ONS showed why the Government had to take "urgent" action to reform public service pensions and to bring forward the increases in state pension ages.

He said: "Later this year we will publish further proposals for a more automatic link between longer lives and the state pension age. We need to make sure that the state pension system is kept on a sustainable footing and that costs are shared fairly between the generations. But we are also determined to make sure that when people do retire they get a decent pension which is why we have restored the link with earnings for the basic state pension".

Armed Forces must wait five years longer for pension

By James Kirkup, and Thomas Harding
9:38PM BST 18 Jun 2012




Soldiers, sailors and airmen may have to give as much as 23 years’ service before being able to leave with their pensions, up from as little as 18 years at present.

The result would be that the effective minimum age for leaving the Services with an immediate pension would increase from 40 to 45.

The plan, disclosed in a Ministry of Defence document, has emerged amid complaints from soldiers that they have been targets for redundancy days before qualifying for their pension. Many soldiers claimed they were sacked and denied an immediate pension, in some cases after the MoD miscalculated the length of their service.

To reflect the risks and rigours of military service, Armed Forces pension rules allow Service personnel to retire and take part of their pension relatively early.

Under the main Forces pension scheme, personnel aged over 40 who have served for at least 18 years get the right to claim an immediate pension and tax-free lump sum on leaving, and a second lump sum when they turn 65.

However, most officers can take advantage of a better deal that allows them to qualify for an immediate pension after 16 years, typically leaving with an annual income of around £12,000, and a larger lump sum when they reach the civilian retirement age.

Under a review known as the New Employment Model (NEM), the Coalition is planning an overhaul in the terms and conditions of employment in the Armed Forces.

The study is confidential, but details have been disclosed in an internal presentation for Armed Forces personnel to prepare them for changes in their pensions.

The prospect of an early pension is a major recruiting tool used by the Armed Forces. Defence chiefs also use it to persuade valued officers and senior non-commissioned officers to remain in service.

However, the system is expensive. The MoD estimates that one third of the money it spends on pensions goes on Early Departure Payments to people who have left services before the age of 55.

To cut that cost, the NEM has recommended a significant increase in the thresholds for early pension payments. The minimum increase in service recommended by the NEM study is two years, but the maximum is five years.

The exact increase in the threshold is subject to a consultation with Service personnel, but will not be popular. “A lot of guys who are mid-career are basically hanging on for the [immediate pension] — another five years would be hard to take,” said one serving officer.

An MoD spokesman confirmed the proposals, but said pensions would still be generous.

The department is also cutting costs by reducing the Army from 102,000 to 82,000, and last week announced a fresh round of redundancies. Some of those affected believe they have been laid off because they are approaching immediate pension age and several accused the MoD of deliberately miscalculating their entitlement.

“The redundancy paperwork that the Army gave me is incorrect, but I stand to be made redundant approximately eight months from immediate pension point (IPP),” said a major with 15 years’ service.

Another major said he knew of 38 officers who were “targeted specifically because we were pre-IPP and therefore cheaper to get rid of”.

The MoD insisted that no personnel had been targets for redundancy, and said the compensation scheme more than made up for the loss of an immediate pension.

Sunday, 17 June 2012

Partitioning The UK?

http://www.boloji.com/index.cfm?md=Content&sd=Articles&ArticleID=12341
by Dr. A. Adityanjee

History In Making:
Francis Fukuyama, that naïve American thinker in 1989 in his infamous essay predicted the end of History and followed up the same thesis in his book in 1992. He was so humbled by the geopolitical tsunamis that have followed in the last two decades witnessing two major wars in the Persian gulf and the Af-Pak region; break-up of Soviet Union and Yugoslavia, divorce of the Czech Republic and Slovakia, toppling of some Arab Despots in South-West Asia; and emergence of new nations like Eritrea, Kosovo, Macedonia, and South Sudan. History was, indeed, made in 1947 when the Imperial British Government abdicated its legal responsibility to control a murderous call for “direct action” and hurriedly partitioned the Colonized India into the Republic of India and the Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
History would be made indeed, in a sudden twist of fate, if the UK gets partitioned in 2014. Following a referendum, an independent Scotland, in all probability, may separate from the Westminster government charting its own future course within the European Union (EU) as an independent nation. On May 25th 2012 Scottish politicians, celebrities and activists in Edinburgh urged a million Scots to sign a declaration of independence that would put “Scotland’s future “in Scotland’s hands.”
The Scottish Refrendum:
Now it is certain that a referendum on the issue of independence will be held in Scotland in 2014. Although Scottish public currently is 57% opposed to the idea of Scottish independence, nationalism is very potent spirit that changes the public opinion in a matter of days. The Scottish National Party (SNP) is in power currently in Holyrood, Edinburgh and the Scottish First Minister (Chief Minister), Alex Salmond is strongly spearheading the Scottish independence campaign. He articulates cogently:
“An independent Scotland can be a beacon for progressive opinion south of the border and further afield, addressing policy challenges in ways that reflect the universal values of fairness and capable of being considered, adapted and implemented according to the circumstances and wishes within the other jurisdiction of these islands and beyond”. UK Prime Minister David Cameron has vowed to “fight with everything I have to keep out United Kingdom together”. He further states: “To me, this is not some issue of policy or strategy or calculation - it matters head, heart and soul. Out shared home is under threat and everyone who cares about needs to speak out”.
For the next two and half years a sustained debate on divorce, harsh rhetoric generated from both the sides and rekindled nationalistic fervor in Scotland may eventually swamp the status quo.
The mainstream UK politicians from the three large parties (Tories, Labor and Liberal-democrats) have tried to scare the hell out of Scottish voters. They would allow only two options in the referendum; keep the status quo or have total independence in the 2014 referendum. Alex Salmond and the SNP have demanded a third option of home rule also that would entail maximum devolution of powers under the UK (so-called Devo Max, Devo plus or independence-lite option).

In 2011, the UK treasury said the level of public spending per head in Scotland was 1624 pounds higher than in England. The debt to the UK tax-payers for bailing out the Royal Bank of Scotland was 26 billion pounds. Inherent is the implicit threat that with total independence comes the fiscal responsibility.
The differences between the two sides are indeed very real and as Salmond highlights:
“The problem with Scotland’s current constitutional settlement is that we can not innovate as much as we would like. Policy choices made in Westminster-by parties whose democratic mandate in Scotland is negligible—are constraining policy choices made in Scotland, for which there is an unequivocal mandate.”
Scottish Social Attitudes Survey done in 2009 found that 61 % of Scots trusted the Scottish government to act in Scotland’s interest versus 25% who trusted the British government.
Those who argue that Scotland would be too small to go it alone forget that with a population of 5.2 million, an independent Scotland would be comparable to other European mini-states, e.g. Croatia 4.41 million, Denmark 5.5 million, Estonia 1.34 million, Finland 5.3 million, Macedonia 2.04 million, Norway 4.7 million, Ireland 4.6 million, Kosovo 2.4 million, Latvia 2.24 million, Lithuania 3.26 million, Slovenia 2.03 million and Slovakia 5.5 million. It will certainly be larger in population than tiny Montenegro with a population of less than one million (626000).
Scotland would have anywhere from 81% to 90% control over the North Sea Oil and 8% share of UK’s assets and liabilities. UK’s national debt of 1.1 trillion pounds and the 8% share of Scotland (in proportion to Scottish population) would come to 88 billion pounds of debt independent Scotland will have to cope with. North Sea Oil has so far generated 250 billion pounds revenue for the UK central government.

Despite decline in yield 6% per year, further pumping of crude would generate further 54 billion pounds in the six years to 2016/17.
International Significance:
Any divorce and demise of the UK, as we currently know it, will have real international geopolitical consequences. Mr. Salmond highlights the implications when he states:
“Scotland as an independent nation would play an active and responsible role in the international community, contributing on issues where it could, but without delusions of grandeur. I find it inconceivable, for instance, that an independent Scotland would ever have participated in the invasion of Iraq.”
Perhaps, the European Union would be over-eager to embrace an independent Scotland because of highly ambivalent relationship with UK.
Following the World War II, the UK, one of the major colonial powers, was forced to give up its colonial possessions owing to changed geo-political circumstances and its fiscal inability to project power internationally. With a deeply contracted economy, a bankrupt Britain was unable to overextend its forces. It started decolonization process reluctantly and slowly.

Liberation of Scotland from the UK would be an ultimate exercise in decolonization since the time original Scottish parliament (Estates of Scotland) was dissolved in 1707 under pressure by the Act of Union 1707 to form a Parliament of the Great Britain. Establishment of an Independent Scotland would unleash the genie of a chain reaction leading ultimately to dissolution of the UK. After independence of Ireland from the UK in 1922, Northern Ireland was retained as a province of the UK. Independent Scotland will act as catalyst to spearhead the drive for re-unification of the eight counties of the Northern Ireland with the rest of Ireland and lead to a united republic of Ireland. In this context one recalls the correspondence and contacts between the Irish freedom fighter Hugo de Valera and MK Gandhi in the early part of the 20th century.

Both these wise men appreciated the predicament of their respective countries and provided moral support for the idea of total independence from Britain.
Since the end of WWII, UK has had a disproportionate influence on international affairs. Some of this was achieved by a Machiavellian “special relationship” with the reigning super-power, US earning it the nick-name “America’s poodle”.

The fact that it was a former colonial power and continued to have a permanent seat on the United Nations’ Security Council helped UK wield undue geo-political influence that was not commensurate with its economic, mercantile and military power or so-called comprehensive national power. 

The fact that the UK chose to exercise its soft power judiciously by using British Council scholarships for academics and civil servants from the former colonies served British geo-political interests very well. UK used its higher education system, especially Cambridge and Oxford Universities to continue to impart its footprint on the psyche of newly minted mandarins from the former colonies who liked to be perceived as “British trained” or “UK returned”. UK cleverly continued to hang on to the former colonial possessions by stitching them together in the glue of the Commonwealth.

However, after the possible secession of Scotland in 2014 and after the eventual dissolution of the UK, perhaps a tiny England may not be able to hold on to its seat on P5 in the UNSC. This would also have bearing on the remaining 14 British overseas territories (or colonies still under possession of the UK), e.g. Falklands, Bermuda, Jersey Island, Montserrat, Cayman Island, Isle of Man, British Virgin Islands, Gibraltar, Diego Garcia, St. Lucia etc. Will Falkland be still under English control in 2015 is a question English policy establishment needs to ponder over!
UK: Rip
2014 may well be the watershed year that would lead to eventual independence of three new European countries historically colonized by the Imperial England, namely Scotland, Wales and the Duchy of Cornwall. If and when that happens, the United Kingdom will be allowed to fade away into geo-political oblivion. Perhaps, at that juncture, a diminished England may choose to republicanize the nation, frame a new written constitution that it currently lacks, have a codified bill of rights, abolish the hereditary House of the Lords, retire the anachronistic Windsors (the English royal family) permanently and award them an annual “privy purse” as compensation just like India did! Such a roadmap may ultimately lead to a tiny England joining the USA as the 51st state just like Hawaii in order to maintain that “special relationship”.
Geo-Political Implications for India:
As the former colonial power, the UK had immense influence on the history of India that still has its impact. Partitioning India and consequent creation of a congenitally antagonistic state of Pakistan was a clever, Machiavellian geo-political ploy by the UK to have her strategic influence in the subcontinent while playing footsie with Pakistan. UK has sided with Pakistan historically on almost every issue of significance to India, starting with the accession of the former princely state of the Jammu and Kashmir. UK continues to meddle in the J& K affairs and inserts itself into every opportunity. UK was the fountainhead of encouragement to the Khalistani separatist movement along with US and Canada while being in bed with Pakistan on this issue. Khalistani separatist leader Jagjeet Singh Chohan was based in London for years under the benevolent patronage of the British Crown. Tamil separatists are traditionally based in UK with their anti-Srilanka activities but also anti-India activities. UK used the state visit of her Queen to humble India by demanding separate state addresses by the British monarch in both Chennai Rajbhavan and Chandigarh Rajbhavan besides a state address in Rashtrapati Bhavan in New Delhi! This would have been a very clear violation of the diplomatic protocol and India’s sovereignty.
UK still has thousands of stolen artifacts from India in its museums, art galleries and private art collections. Unlike the Greeks who have made formal demand for return of the Elgin marbles from London, the Government of India has not had the courage to legally demand repatriation of plundered arts and archeological treasures. Nor did Government of India hold the British Empire and its mandarins responsible for genocide of Indians during the Great famine of Bengal in the 1940s. Unlike Israel which has pursued the former Nazis tenaciously wherever they fled to; Government of India abdicated her national responsibility in bringing the former colonial masters to justice. Perhaps, there will be window of opportunity to get all the stolen treasures repatriated from English museums after the dissolution of the UK. A thoroughly weakened and emasculated England would not be able to justify continuing to hoard stolen Indian treasures and cultural artifacts. Lastly, a fragmented England would not be able to play its Pro-Pakistan game on the issue of J&K.
Engaging Scotland:
India must keenly watch the events leading to the Scottish referendum of 2014 and engage the Scottish political elite in advance so that India as an emerging super-power is not left out of policy options. India needs to use the principle of reciprocity in international relations. India must not forget the lessons of history. India has to resolve the outstanding issues left over from the history with the UK or its successor state. India needs to be pro-active instead of reactive in her policy formulations. India needs to shape the geopolitical events by exercising her smart power. Here is a golden opportunity for India to address and correct some of the injustices that were heaped on her in the past.

Unfortunately, India is going through a political and economic turmoil with national (parliamentary) elections scheduled for 2014. Another uncertain electoral outcome may plunge the country further deep into political as well as policy paralysis. Therefore, time is ripe now for the mandarins in the MEA to start formulating contingency plans, should an independent Scotland become a geopolitical reality in 2014. Starting with a Strategic Partnership Agreement, an extradition treaty and a Double Taxation Avoidance Treaty, the bilateral focus should be on tighter economic relationship with Scotland. North Sea oil could be imported from Scotland for the hydrocarbon needs of an energy starved India. The Tatas (who currently own the British luxury Jaguar Land Rover brand) should consider relocating their car production plants from England to up north in Scotland. The Mahindras should consider building their new SUV production plans in Scotland. Indian business houses should invest in newly independent Scotland when that reality emerges.
As a nation formerly colonized by UK, almost all Indians would experience an exhilarating feeling of schadenfreude at the independence of Scotland and possible disintegration of the UK as we know it. India should act as a de facto midwife in the birth of the new nation of independent Scotland. Just like India gave her voice for the cause of decolonization of Africa, it must provide moral, material and diplomatic support for the idea of Scottish independence from the UK because it is the right thing to do.

Government of India should be the first country to formally recognize an independent Scotland as and when it formally secedes from the UK. Indian civil society needs to engage with the Scottish civil society in harboring a new geopolitical reality. The naysayers had predicted breakdown of India after the British left in 1947. Despite being a “functioning anarchy” and having a “Hindu Rate of Growth”, India survives while the UK faces imminent partition, fragmentation and demise of the union. The same Nattering Nabobs of Negativism have lampooned an independent Scotland to be a “Skintland” with capital “Edinborrow”. They will be proven wrong once again!

Methinks that the juggernaut of independent Scotland is too strong to be stopped. Demise of the UK is just round the corner!

14-Jun-2012

£1 billion deal paves the way for Trident nuclear deterrent replacement

By Robert Watts, and Patrick Hennessy
8:30PM BST 16 Jun 2012




Philip Hammond, the Defence Secretary, will reveal the scheme to build a new nuclear deterrent in a move which will cause tensions with the Liberal Democrats.

He will announce a deal ordering nuclear reactors for a new class of submarines to replace the current Vanguard fleet, which carries Britain’s Trident nuclear arsenal.

The decision is the most public statement yet that the Government is committed to a full-scale replacement of Trident - something opposed by the Lib Dems, who want a cheaper way of maintaining nuclear weapons.

Mr Hammond will say that a Rolls-Royce plant at Raynesway, in Derby, will be given the order to build the reactors, and that the Ministry of Defence will fund an 11-year refit of the plant.

The contract will create 300 jobs and many more in the factory’s supply chain.

But it will create a rift with the Liberal Democrats. One senior Liberal Democrat source told The Sunday Telegraph this weekend that the replacement of Trident remains a “massive fault line” between the Coalition’s two parties.

The Lib Dems pledged in their 2010 manifesto that they would oppose a “like-for-like” replacement of the submarines and the nuclear warhead-carrying missiles which they fire.

Nick Harvey, the Lib Dem defence minister, is leading a review into cheaper ways to maintain the nuclear deterrent and wants to abandon the so-called “Moscow criterion”, which recommends Britain retains an arsenal capable of destroying the Russian capital.

The new contract, to be announced in the next few days, represents the Government’s biggest commitment to replacing the ageing Trident fleet, at a total cost of up to £20billion.

Ministry of Defence sources said that it was possible to go ahead with the reactor contract now because defence cuts and reforms to procurement meant new investments could begin.

A senior MoD source said: “This is good news for the Royal Navy and a great boost for jobs. These cutting edge reactors will support the UK’s submarines for decades and are a vital part of ordering long lead items for the new nuclear deterrent submarines.

“We have balanced the MoD’s books and can now get on with ordering major pieces of equipment for the armed forces to protect us against future threats.”

Conservatives are determined to replace “like for like” the Vanguard submarines, which are expected to be decommissioned in the late 2020s, Their Trident II D-5 missiles are expected to remain in service until 2042. It is undecided whether the Government will opt for three or four submarines.

Twenty years after the end of the Cold War, there are many new threats to international security, with growing fears surrounding Iran, China and Russia, Conservatives say. It is also claimed that failing to commission a new wave of submarines could cost up to 15,000 British jobs.

Although the Coalition Agreement between the Tories and Lib Dems said the parties would “maintain Britain’s nuclear deterrent”, it also said that “Liberal Democrats will continue to make the case for alternatives”.

A £350million contract to design the new submarines went to BAE Systems, Babcock and Rolls-Royce. But the symbolism of ordering reactors is far greater.

The new nuclear submarine contract with Rolls-Royce will be seen as one in a series of policies launched by the Tories which are designed to reconnect with the party’s grassroots. In recent weeks, Conservative ministers have unveil a crackdown on illegal immigrants and foreign prisoners, pledged new action on anti-social families and given ground on the prospect of a referendum on Britain’s membership of the EU.

The decision by Conservatives ministers to sign such a high-profile contract comes at a time of tense relations between the two parties. Many Tory MPs are seething with the Lib Dems for failing to support Jeremy Hunt in last week’s Commons motion calling for an investigation into the Culture Secretary’s handling of News Corporation’s BSkyB bid.

And it was made despite Sir Menzies Campbell, the Lib Dem grandee, making an open public call for ministers to abandon the “Moscow criterion”.

“Nuclear weapons have no intrinsic merit,” the party’s former leader said recently, adding that “it is unthinkable today that Britain would contemplate the destruction of the heavily populated capital of Russia – or any other city.”

However, opposition to a new generation of nuclear weapons will not be confined to Liberal Democrats. A poll two years ago found that 63% of the public said they supported scrapping Britain’s nuclear deterrent to cut the deficit in the public finances.

Some senior military figures have also opposed Trident, arguing that it consumes too much of the defence budget and leaves less money for front-line forces.

General Lord Dannatt, the former chief of the army staff, previously said in an interview: “It is a very fine judgement as to whether we should continue to have a nuclear deterrent or not.

“I think if we are looking at the character and nature of future conflicts and if we think we will be dealing with hybrid warfare or asymmetric threats, then may be for the next few years it makes sense to keep that ultimate deterrent in case some government in five, ten, or 15 years would want to threaten the security of our country.

“At present we should keep it but not forever.”

The push towards a new generation of nuclear submarines comes as the military is facing deep cuts, with the number of armed forces personnel set to be cut from 180,000 to 150,000 over the next five years.

A report published earlier this year by CentreForum, a liberal think tank, said: “Replacing Trident is nonsensical. There is no current or medium-term threat to the UK which justifies the huge costs involved.

"A critical assessment of the UK’s strategic position and military requirements leads to a clear conclusion: Trident makes no effective contribution to our security.

"Cancelling it will provide a unique opportunity to re-balance and revitalise Britain’s forces for the 21st century.”

Wednesday, 13 June 2012

Thousands of troops lose jobs today in biggest redundancy cull for decades

6:00AM BST 12 Jun 2012




At 9am this morning thousands of soldiers, sailors and airmen from across the country will be ordered to appear before their commanding officers and handed their redundancy letters.

The biggest redundancy of service personnel for two decades will see a cull of mid-ranking officers who have gained the most operational experience in a generation with the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Officers starting their advanced course at the Joint Services Command and Staff College in Shrivenham said they were waiting the news with “great trepidation” last night.

“We have all been on near constant operations for almost a decade but some of us know it’s going to be good bye tomorrow without much gratitude or respect for all we and our families have gone through,” said one officer. “You can imagine the state of moral.”

The axing of 4,100 troops from all three Services comes as the Armed Forces reduces from 180,000 to 150,000 over the next five years as part of cost-saving defence cuts.

But Andrew Robathan, the Defence Minister, said: the MOD would "retain the capabilities that our Armed Forces require in order to meet the challenges of the future".

Almost 3,000 soldiers were sacked in the first round of sackings last September. The second round will be the last tranche of redundancies for the Navy and the RAF with the Army expecting a third tranche later this year. It is expected up to a third have asked for voluntary redundancy.

But Labour said the Government must do more to demonstrate how the Armed Forces would meet future demands and criticised the continued uncertainty over changes to regimental structures.

Jim Murphy, the shadow defence secretary, said: "We are concerned about the human and military impact of these job losses. Capability is being lost, as are people's livelihoods.

"The Government has focused on structures not purpose. Savings have to be made but ministers must do much more to explain our future ability to project force around the world as well as how they intend to support the thousands being sacked.

"The Government are not reforming but dithering. We have no final decisions on the future of basing or regiments and the continued uncertainty is deeply debilitating."

Up to 2,900 Army personnel will be told of their fate, as will up to 900 members of the RAF and up to 300 from the Royal Navy in the latest tranche of military job cuts.
It will be the second round of redundancies - including a mixture of voluntary and compulsory - resulting from the 2010 Strategic Defence and Security Review.

Thursday, 31 May 2012

BAE plans to cut 600 jobs in Newcastle

By Graham Ruddick

11:03AM BST 31 May 2012




The defence company is battling to deal with spending cuts by the Government and has already cut thousands of jobs in the UK.

The Newcastle site is producing the Terrier engineering vehicle but BAE says there is “no prospect of new UK armoured vehicle manufacturing” beyond the end of 2013, when it plans to close the factory.

BAE has launched consultations with trade unions about cutting 330 jobs at Newcastle as well as 280 at its munitions business in Crewe, Washington in the north east, and Glascoed in south Wales. A further ten jobs could be lost at BAE’s head office in Farnborough.

Following the cuts, BAE says it will consolidate its UK armoured vehicle support work in Telford.

Charlie Blakemore, BAE managing director, said: “We need to adapt to very challenging market conditions and further reduce our overheads to drive better value for our customers and increase our competitiveness in the export market.

“I know that this is difficult news for employees and we will do all we can to help them through this difficult period and mitigate the proposed job losses wherever possible.”

Choosing who lives and who dies: the methodical assassinations of Barack Obama's 'kill list'

By David Blair/ Last updated: May 30th, 2012




There is something deeply unsettling about the disclosure in The New York Times that America has developed a clinical, dispassionate procedure for selecting the targets of drone strikes in Pakistan, Yemen and Somalia.

Every week or so, about 100 national security officials gather by video conference to pore over the photographs and biographies of al-Qaeda terrorists. They decide who should be spared and who should be marked for death.

Those “nominated” for assassination (yes, “nominated” is apparently the official word) are placed on a “kill list” that passes directly to Barack Obama.

He then exercises the judgment of Solomon, going through the list name by name and deciding who will die. The CIA’s drones are then programmed to dispatch the President’s chosen targets.

The aim is to keep the drones on a “tight leash”, to use Obama’s phrase, and ensure that killings only happen with the strictest oversight.

This procedure has been revealed presumably because the White House wants to reassure us that drones are not dealing death from the skies at random. The fact that it is all so methodical is supposed to be a virtue. Nonetheless, the idea that a formal process has developed at all is grounds for deep discomfort.

I have a minor personal connection with this argument. Back in 2002 – 03, I happened to interview three senior figures in Hamas, all of whom were later assassinated by Israeli missile strikes.



Within months of my meeting Abdel-Aziz Rantissi, Ismail Abu Shanab and Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, each had fallen victim to carefully targeted, clinical operations of the kind that Obama now approves week by week.

But things were different then. Whenever Israel assassinated a Hamas leader, the world would voice its outrage. Pretty much every country – including America – would issue a statement of condemnation. The US would say that it disapproved of extra-judicial killings. Meanwhile, Britain would get quite worked up.

I remember Jack Straw, then Foreign Secretary, expressing great indignation when Rantissi was dispatched by an Israeli missile within weeks of succeeding Yassin as Hamas leader in 2004.

The fact that targeted assassinations are now happening on a far wider scale – with a fraction of the protest – shows how much the world has changed.

There is no doubt that drones have become the single most effective counter-terrorism weapon in the US arsenal. Few doubt that al-Qaeda has been crippled by the systematic elimination of its core leadership. Obama can credibly argue that lives have duly been saved.

But in his inaugural address back in January 2009, he also said: “We reject as false the choice between our safety and our ideals.” The fact that he now pores over death lists shows the utter fatuity of that statement. The tension between safety and idealism, between liberty and security, is ever-present and unavoidable. As of today, Obama’s point on that spectrum is to believe that he can take upon himself the right to decide who lives and who dies.

His defence will be that he deals death in the cause of saving lives. The drones have doubtless averted terrorist attacks; many people are alive today only because they happened.

When I was a student, the first philosophical question I was set was the proposition that the greatest happiness of the greatest number should always prevail. I read about how this crude utilitarian calculation was morally indefensible in the modern world because it inevitably entailed the end justifying the means. It seems we are all utilitarians now.

It may seem painless, but drone war in Afghanistan is destroying the West's reputation

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/afghanistan/9300187/It-may-seem-painless-but-drone-war-in-Afghanistan-is-destroying-the-Wests-reputation.html

7:51PM BST 30 May 2012

The theory and practice of warfare has evolved with amazing speed since al-Qaeda’s attack on mainland America in September, 2001. In less than 11 years it is already possible to discern three separate phases.

First, we had the era of ground invasion followed by military occupation. This concept, which feels terribly 20th-century today, appeared at first to work well, with the fall of the Taliban in Afghanistan followed by the easy destruction of Saddam Hussein in Iraq.

But by 2005, it was obvious that the strategy was failing. The resurgence of the Taliban, and the success of the Iraqi insurgencies, led to an urgent reassessment.

In desperation, the United States turned to the more sophisticated methodology once favoured by the British and before them the Romans – the elaboration of a system of alliances, otherwise known as “divide and rule”.

This was the second phase, the “surge” of 2007, which made the reputation of General David Petraeus and rescued the second Bush presidency from disaster.

Of greater significance than the temporary increase in troop numbers on the ground was the decision by the Western Iraqi tribes, encouraged by the payment of enormous bribes, to detach themselves, at least temporarily, from al-Qaeda.

The same tactics did not work, however, when duplicated two years later in Afghanistan – and so US policy has unobtrusively moved into a third phase: a new and as yet only partially understood doctrine of secret, unaccountable and illegal warfare.

The guiding force has once again been General Petraeus, who is already being tipped as favourite to win the Republican nomination in the 2016 presidential elections.

Appointed director of the CIA last summer, he is converting the intelligence agency into a paramilitary organisation.

Conventional military forces are scarcely relevant: it is Petraeus who now masterminds what George Bush used to call the “war on terror” from the CIA headquarters in Langley, Virginia.

President Obama has reportedly allowed his CIA chief to deepen the connection between Special Forces and secret intelligence, a potentially unconstitutional move because it can mean that military operations are no longer answerable to Congress.

More important still, the CIA also seems to mastermind and direct the drone strikes which have suddenly become the central element of US (and therefore British) military strategy.

Even 10 years ago, drones – remotely operated killing machines – were unthinkable because they seemed to spring direct from the imagination of a deranged science-fiction movie director. But today they dominate. Already, more US armed forces personnel are being trained as drone operators (computer geeks who sit in front of a computer screen somewhere in the mid-west of America doling out real-life death and destruction) than air force pilots.

It is easy to understand why. First of all, they can be deadly accurate. Tribal Afghans have been amazed not just that the car a Taliban leader was travelling in was precisely targeted – but that the missile went in through the door on the side he was sitting. The US claims that drones have proved very effective at targeting and killing Taliban or al-Qaeda leaders, but with the very minimum of civilian casualties.

Second, US soldiers and airmen are not placed in harm’s way. This is very important in a democracy. In America, the killing of a dozen military personnel is a political event. The death of a dozen Afghan or Pakistani villagers in a remote part of what used to be called the north‑west frontier does not register, unless a US military spokesmen labels them “militants”, in which case it becomes a victory.

There is no surprise, then – as the New York Times revealed in an important article on Tuesday – that Mr Obama “has placed himself at the helm of a top secret 'nominations’ process to designate terrorists for kill or capture, of which the capture part has become largely theoretical”.

The least enviable task of an old-fashioned British home secretary was to sign the death warrant for convicted murderers.



According to the New York Times, the President has taken these exquisite agonies one stage further: “When a rare opportunity for a drone strike at a top terrorist arises, but his family is with him, it is the President who has reserved to himself the final moral calculation.”

So, in the US, drone strikes are a good thing. In Pakistan, from where I write this, it is impossible to overestimate the anger and distress they cause.

Almost all Pakistanis feel that they are personally under attack, and that America tramples on their precarious national sovereignty.

There are good reasons for this. When, last year in Lahore, an out-of-control CIA operative shot dead two reportedly unarmed Pakistanis, and his follow-up car ran over and killed a third, the American was spirited out of the country.

Meanwhile, America refuses to apologise for killing 24 Pakistani servicemen in a botched ISAF operation. This is election year and Mr Obama, having apologised already over Koran-burning, may be nervous about a second apology, and has therefore confined himself to an expression of “regret”.

I am told by a number of credible sources that this refusal to behave decently – allied to dismay at the use of drones as the weapon of default in tribal areas – is the reason for the unusual decision of the US ambassador in Islamabad, Cameron Munter, to step down after less than two years in his post.

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton – increasingly irrelevant and marginalised in an administration dominated by the partnership between Leon Panetta, the Secretary of Defence, and Petraeus – has protested but been ignored.

We need a serious public debate on drones. They are still in their infancy, but have already changed the nature of warfare. The new technology points the way, within just a few decades, to a battlefield where soldiers never die or even risk their lives, and only alleged enemies of the state, their family members, and civilians die in combat – a world straight out of the mouse’s tale in Alice in Wonderland: “ 'I’ll be judge, I’ll be jury’, said cunning old Fury. 'I’ll try the whole cause and condemn you to death.’ ” Justice as dealt out by drones cannot be reconciled with the rule of law which we say we wish to defend.

Supporters of drones – and they make up practically the entire respectable political establishment in Britain and the US – argue that they are indispensable in the fight against al-Qaeda. But plenty of very experienced voices have expressed profound qualms.

The former army officer David Kilcullen, one of the architects of the 2007 Iraqi surge, has warned that drone attacks create more extremists than they eliminate. Sir Sherard Cowper-Coles, Britain’s former special representative to Afghanistan and Pakistan, is equally adamant that drone attacks are horribly counter-productive because of the hatred they have started to generate: according to a recent poll, more than two thirds of Pakistanis regard the United States as an enemy.

Britain used to be popular and respected in this part of the world for our wisdom and decency. Now, thanks to our refusal to challenge American military doctrine, we are hated, too.

Wednesday, 23 May 2012

U.K. Presses On With Designs for Nuke Sub Replacement

May. 22, 2012 - 10:37AM   |  By ANDREW CHUTER   |

http://www.defensenews.com/article/20120522/DEFREG01/305220004/U-K-Presses-Designs-Nuke-Sub-Replacement?odyssey=tab|topnews|text|FRONTPAGE



LONDON — The British government has awarded industry 350 million pounds ($553.5 million) in contracts to continue design work on the Royal Navy’s replacement for its current nuclear missile-equipped submarines.

BAE Systems was the main beneficiary of the May 22 contract announcement by the Ministry of Defence. The submarine builder accounted for 328 million pounds of the spending, while Babcock secured a 15 million pound deal on designing parts of the in-service support and nuclear reactor builder Rolls-Royce has been awarded a 4 million pound contract.

The contracts are part of a 3 billion pound design effort the MoD announced 12 months ago.

Defence Secretary Philip Hammond said the contracts were an “important step” toward renewing the U.K.’s nuclear deterrent.

Britain is in the early stages of designing a new submarine to replace its four Vanguard-class boats. The first of the new Successor program submarines is due to be delivered to the Royal Navy in 2028. The submarine is expected to provide the deterrent capability into the 2060s. A final decision on the design and build program for the Trident missile-equipped submarine is not scheduled to be made until 2016.

No decision has been announced on whether the British will build three or four new submarines.

BAE is currently building the seven-strong Astute class of nuclear attack submarines for the Royal Navy at its yard in Barrow-in-Furness, northeast England.

John Hudson, the managing director for BAE’s submarine building operation, said the new deal was a key step in sustaining and growing jobs and skills through the Astute program and into the Successor effort.

The design contracts awards come as the Conservative-led coalition government continues a review into alternative, less expensive ways of maintaining the nuclear deterrent to appease its junior partners, the Liberal Democrats. A report is expected later this year.
Last week, the MoD announced it was spending 5 billion pounds over five years at the Atomic Weapons Establishment to help keep the existing warhead used on Trident in service, as well as retain the ability to design and build a new warhead. About 40 percent of the spending is on capital projects.