Showing posts with label Indian Defence News. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indian Defence News. Show all posts

Wednesday, 20 June 2012

Indian Minister Rejects Charges Connected With Sub Deal



Jun. 19, 2012 - 11:11AM   |   By VIVEK RAGHUVANSHI


NEW DELHI — Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee, the ruling United Progressive Alliance Party’s presidential nominee, has denied accusations from a prominent social activist who said Mukherjee has been slow to look into charges of corruption involving India’s purchase of Scorpene submarines.

Arvind Kejriwal, an associate of Anna Hazare, who has been spearheading a movement against corruption in public life here, has demanded an inquiry into the charges against Mukherjee ahead of the July 19 presidential election.

In a June 17 news conference, Kejriwal noted the Scorpene deal was contracted with France in 2005, when Mukherjee was defense minister, but Mukherjee has failed to investigate allegations of kickbacks paid to Indian officials in connection with the deal.

“The president’s post is the highest constitutional office of the country, and the person donning it must be aboveboard and free from any allegation,” Kejriwal said.

Denying the charges, Mukherjee said June 18 that the allegations were “false, self-seeking, mala-fide and made with ulterior motive and lacking any form of responsibility.”

State-owned Mazagon Docks Ltd. is building the six Scorpenes at its Mumbai shipyard under license from France’s DCNS.
The submarines were due for delivery beginning this year under a $3.9 billion agreement between India and France. However, the delivery has been delayed to 2015, and the cost of the project has gone up by nearly $1 billion.

Tuesday, 19 June 2012

India Scraps Domestic Jet Engine Plan

Jun. 17, 2012 - 01:46PM   |   By VIVEK RAGHUVANSHI  



http://www.defensenews.com/article/20120617/DEFREG03/306170005/India-Scraps-Domestic-Jet-Engine-Plan?odyssey=mod|newswell|text|World News|s



NEW DELHI — India has abandoned its efforts to build its own engine to power the Light Combat Aircraft (LCA) Mark-2, according to Indian Defence Ministry sources.

The Kaveri engine, which Indian defense scientists are trying to build, has failed to meet Indian Air Force requirements two decades after the project began, the MoD sources said.

This means the LCA Mark-2 will be powered only by U.S. company General Electric’s GE-414 engine, which was short-listed earlier over Germany’s Eurojet to power the LCA Mark-2. The aircraft, under development at Bangalore’s Aeronautical Development Agency, is expected to be ready around 2017.

While an MoD official would not say that the engine project has been abandoned for the aircraft, he did say that the Kaveri engine does not fully meet the Air Force’s thrust requirements. The MoD has now decided to use the Kaveri engine to power only UAVs, the official added.

India’s Defence Research and Development Organization (DRDO), the agency that is building the Kaveri, had been in consultation with French company Snecma for the past three years to help complete the engine.

DRDO and Snecma had been negotiating to co-develop and co-produce the engine, but they have yet to sign an agreement, the MoD official said.

While the official would not say why the negotiations failed, an Indian Air Force source said the Kaveri project to power the LCA has been all but abandoned. Beyond powering UAVs, the engine also will be a technology demonstration project.

The Air Force source added that besides the failure to meet the thrust level, the Kaveri also has technical problems with its compressor, turbine and engine control system.

Meanwhile, the LCA Mark-1 is readying for induction by 2014, nearly 15 years behind schedule. It will be powered by the GE-404 engine, also from General Electric.

For the LCA Mark-2 program, ADA will order 99 GE-414 engines and the rest will be manufactured in India under technology transfer arrangements.

India to launch AWACS project


NEW DELHI: With Pakistan stealing a swift march in the "eyes in the sky" arena and China already way ahead, India is now going to launch its own full-blown futuristic AWACS (airborne warning and control system) programme.



"Clearances are underway" to initially develop two AWACS aircraft, with four more to follow at a later stage, under the new `AWACS-India' project to be executed by DRDO and its Bangalore-based Centre for Air Borne Systems (CABS).



"Under it, 360-degree AESA (active electronically scanned array) radars will be mounted on large aircraft like IL-76, Boeing or Airbus," said a DRDO source.



Potent force-multipliers like AWACS or AEW&C (airborne early warning and control) systems have changed the entire nature of air warfare because they can detect incoming aerial threats, ranging from fighters to cruise missiles, much before ground-based radars.



They also serve to direct air defence fighters during combat operations with enemy jets and also help in tracking troop build-ups.



Pakistan already has four Swedish Saab-2000 AEW&C aircraft, with four more Chinese ZDK-03 AWACS in the pipeline. China has around 20 AWACS, a mix of new and old systems, say sources.



But IAF has only three Phalcon AWACS mounted on IL-76 aircraft, under the $1.1 billion tripartite agreement among India, Israel and Russia finalized in 2004, despite being confronted with two potentially hostile fronts.



The case for two additional "follow-on" Phalcon AWACS, with a range of over 400-km and 360-degree coverage like the first three, has run into some rough weather due to sharp cost escalation.



Moreover, DRDO's ongoing mini-AWACS project, under which indigenous AEW&C systems are to be mounted on three Embraer-145 jets obtained from Brazil for $210-million, has also slipped after being approved in October, 2004, at a cost of Rs 1,800 crore.



DRDO, however, contends the project is now on track. "CABS will get the first Embraer, modified with antenna units and other structures mounted on its fuselage, in July," said an official.



"All electronic systems, with a normal radar range of 250-km and 240-degree coverage, will then be integrated. The first flight should take place in early-2013. The project completion date is April 2014," said an official.



IAF is awaiting the completion of the mini-AWACS project as well as the launch of the larger 'AWACS-India' programme with crossed fingers.

Friday, 15 June 2012

4th T-50 Indo-Russian Stealth Fighter To Fly in 2012

 
Russia's United Aircraft Corporation (UAC) said today that it will fly the fourth Sukhoi T-50 stealth fighter into it's test and development program this year. The stealth fighter is being co developed by India and Russia together.

United Aircraft Corporation (UAC) is currently testing three technology demonstrator fighters. A fourth will be brought in this year.

The first production variant of the T-50 will enter service with the Russian Air Force by 2015, and the first evaluation example by 2013. The evaluation version of the fighter will be fully loaded with weapons and the fighter will undergo extensive weapons trials in that period before entering into full service. The Russian air force plans to acquire 60 of the fifth-generation fighters.

The T-50, also known as project PAK-FA, first flew on January 29, 2011 and was first publicly revealed at the Moscow Air Show in August that year. India will also acquire these advanced fighter aircraft based on the T-50. The Indian variant will be slightly different because of different threat perceptions of these two countries.

Indian Coastguard Inducts Griffon Hoverwork Hovercraft H-187

 
The Indian Coast Guard commissioned the Hovercraft H-187 into service at Okha in Gujarat.

H-187 is the first of a line of twelve Air Cushion Vehicles (ACVs) designed and built by Griffon Hoverwork Limited (GHL), UK. It is commanded by Commandant Anurag Kaushik, who is a communication specialist. The hovercraft has a crew of two Officers and 11 Enrolled Personnel (EPs).

H-187 was commissioned by Vice Admiral MP Muralidharan, AVSM, NM, the Director General Indian Coast Guard.

Deputy Inspector General BS Yadav, PTM, Commander Coast Guard Region (North-West) and other officials from the Central and State Government were also present at the induction, according to a Coast Guard statement.

The 21-meter long ACV displaces 31 tonnes and can achieve a maximum speed of 45 knots. The ACV can take on a variety of roles including ‘surveillance, interdiction, search and rescue and rendering assistance to small boats/craft in distress at sea’, according to a statement issued today.

The hovercraft will be under the ‘administrative and operational control of the Commander Coast Guard Region (North-West)’ and will be based at Okha.

US Expects Hike in Arms Sales to India

 
After emerging as one of the top arms supplier to India over the last decade with nearly $8-billion worth of deals, the US is expecting to further hike its military sales to the South Asian nation in 2013 too, building on the boost in the bilateral ties between the two countries and the successful visit of American Defence Secretary Leon Panetta to New Delhi last week.

"We are hopeful that arms sales to India will increase. We’ve made tremendous progress in the relationship over the last decade. We went from nearly zero sales to about $8 billion in sales,” Assistant Secretary of State for Political-Military Affairs Andrew Shapiro was quoted as saying in a media conference.

"Going forward, there’s a number of tenders which we hope we’re successful on, including a tender for Apache (attack) helicopters. We continue to advocate for them, and we’re hopeful that we’ll be successful on a number of sales over the coming year with India,” Shapiro said.

Apart from the tender for 22 attack helicopters in India, US Defence firms are also competing in 15 heavy lift helicopters tenders with their Chinook choppers.

These apart, the US, just a few weeks ago, was chosen by the Indian Defence ministry to supply 145 M777 ultra light howitzers, a final deal under the foreign military sales routes is likely to be signed within a couple of months.

Further, the US is also likely to supply India with its Javelin anti-tank weapon in the near future.

In the last decade, US has won several deals such as 12 P8-I maritime patrol planes, 10 C-17 heavy lift transport planes, six C-130J special forces transport plane, apart from allied weapons systems and other equipment for these flying machines.

Noting that in 2012, the US had already surpassed $50-billion in foreign military sales, Shapiro said this represented at least a $20-billion increase over fiscal year 2011.

"We still have more than a quarter of the fiscal year left,” he said.

The recent years have seen tremendous growth and sales with developing countries and emerging powers such as Brazil and India, he added.

"This speaks volumes about our diplomatic efforts,” he said.

"To put this in context, fiscal year 2011 was a record-setting year at just over $30 billion. This fiscal year will be at least 70 per cent greater than fiscal year 2011. These sales support tens of thousands of American jobs, which is welcome news for the economy,” he said.

The US agreement to expand its security cooperation with Saudi Arabia, in December last year, is likely to have a significant impact on the US economy, supporting over 50,000 jobs.

The $29.4-billion sale to Saudi Arabia included 84 advanced F-15SA fighter aircraft, upgrades to current fleet of 70 F-15 aircraft, as well as munitions, spare parts, training, maintenance and logistics.

This will also bring business to over 600 suppliers in 44 states and provide $3.5-billion in annual economic impact to the US economy.

The deal with Saudi Arabia will support jobs not only in the aerospace sector, but also in US' manufacturing base and support chain, all crucial for sustaining their national Defence.

US also has business from Japan to sell Joint Strike Fighter for about $10 billion, Shapiro said.

Wednesday, 13 June 2012

Most Australians against uranium sale to India: Survey

PTI

Melbourne, June 5: 

The Australian Government might have overturned a ban on uranium sale to India but a majority of people in the country still appear opposed to the idea of selling the mineral to New Delhi.

In a new survey, a majority of Australians were found to be against the recent Labor party decision of lifting the ban on uranium sale to India with 61 per cent opposing it.

“More than 60 per cent of Australians say they are against ‘Australia selling uranium to India’, with 39 per cent saying they are ‘strongly against’,” according to the eight annual Lowy Institute poll 2012.

In December 2011, the Australian Labor Party had overturned a ban on the sale of uranium to India following a heated national conference debate.

The results were published by the Lowy institute Poll after a nationally representative opinion survey of 1,005 Australian adults was done.

Key issues covered in the poll included uranium sale to India, relations with Fiji, the Bali bombings, climate change, the war in Afghanistan, migration, US Presidential elections, US military bases, and attitudes towards democracy and human rights.

The poll also included questions of migration, a perennially controversial topic.

It revealed that Australians recognised the need for short-term migration to address worker shortages with 62 per cent saying they were in favour of ‘the government allowing in extra workers from foreign countries’ when ‘there are shortages of workers in Australia and companies in Australia cannot find enough skilled workers’.

However, it was found that there was major opposition against large-scale foreign investment.

The poll also included several new questions about Australia’s image and engagement with the neighbourhood.

It was found that Australians believe it was important to be liked by neighbours, with 68 per cent saying it was ‘very important’ for ‘Australia to be seen in a positive light by people from countries in region’, with another 26 per cent saying it is ‘somewhat important’.
They also supported the government efforts to communicate with countries in the region.

Monday, 11 June 2012

Tatra: ‘Loopholes’ in reply, CBI to quiz BEML chief again

Rahul Tripathi : New Delhi, Mon Jun 11 2012, 03:18 hrs  




Probing into the alleged irregularities pertaining to the supply of Tatra trucks to the Army, the CBI has found several ‘loopholes’ in the reply provided by Bharat Earth Movers Limited (BEML), the defence PSU.

The all-terrain trucks were being supplied by BEML in collaboration with Tatra Sipox UK. The agency, which began investigations two months ago, had sent a detailed questionnaire to BEML seeking clarification regarding the procurement and indiginisation.

It received the reply on May 31 in which BEML claimed that 62 per cent of indiginisation of Tatra trucks have been completed. However, the MoD-CBI team that recently visited BEML plants in Bangalore had said in its report that not even 30 per cent of indigenisation had been achieved.

The reply provided by Director, defence business, P K Naik also stated that BEML is the custodian of all ‘drawings’ and ‘technical information’ on T 815 models being supplied by Tatra to the Army.

“Despite the BEML claim that they have the drawings and technical information on the variant of Tatra trucks being supplied to the Army, the indiginisation work has not been completed. We are examining the BEML reply in detail and will soon summon them for further examinations,” said a CBI official.

Last month, the CBI had questioned BEML CMD V R S Natarajan. It plans to examine him again on the replies received from BEML.

It was learnt from the examination of BEML’s records and replies that the PSU had taken Rs 30 crore from the Ministry of Defence in 1988 for setting up a plant to manufacture Tatra trucks as technology was being transferred. In its reply the PSU has claimed that no plant has been set up and only a small unit to manufacture gear boxes for Tatra trucks is operational at KGF unit near Bangalore.

After scrutinising the reply, the agency has alleged that BEML, by revising the contract in 2003, helped the entry of two variants of Tatra trucks through the backdoor. “It was found that Tatra Heavy Recovery Vehicle and Tatra’s Crash Fire Tender were made part of the 2003 contract. This was done without carrying out the trial of these vehicles.

The 2003 contract was drawn after revising the 1997 contract which was for 10 years,” said the official.

The agency believes this was done to benefit Ravi Rishi’s Tatra Sipox-Vectra group. Vectra, which has controlling stake in Tatra Sipox UK is under the scanner over alleged irregularities in the supply of trucks.

The agency has registered a case naming Rishi and unnamed officials of the MoD, Army and BEML on March 30 for alleged criminal conspiracy, cheating, and under relevant sections of the Prevention of Corruption Act. The agency is probing into alleged irregularities in assigning of supply from Czechoslovakia-based Tatra, with which the agreement was originally signed in 1986, to the Tatra Sipox UK, owned by Rishi, in 1997, showing it as original equipment manufacturer and fully-owned subsidiary of the Czech company, which was against the provisions of defence procurement procedure.

India is not a global power


Chinmaya R. Gharekhan




Instead of chasing such titles, let us work harder to improve the lives of the poor

Power in inter-state relations is the capacity as well as the political will to use that capacity, of one country to make another country do something which, left to itself, it would not do or would not want to do. “Soft” power should not be considered a component of the concept of power since it is not relevant to modifying the behaviour of another country; it can and does serve as a model and indirectly — and over a period of time — to earn goodwill among sections of society of other countries for its culture.

But it has no place in the discussion of power as a means to bring about a change in the attitude of another country. India has a genuine attraction for many in the Middle East because of its pluralism combined with a functioning democracy; however, it does not give any “power” to India to influence decision-making in those countries.

When we talk of power, we are thinking of military, economic and diplomatic clout, not of Bollywood or yoga.

Spheres of influence


The 20th century offers many examples of the exercise of power by states mostly in neighbouring countries or countries regarded as forming a part of their spheres of influence.

There were at least 10 cases of American intervention, starting with Cuba when the Platt amendment was adopted in the Senate which gave virtual control over Cuba to the U.S. as well as provided the framework for the lease of Guantánamo Bay.

Other examples are Panama in 1903, Nicaragua in 1912, Haiti in 1915, the Bay of Pigs fiasco in 1961, Chile in 1973, etc.

An example of the blatant exercise of power was the Anglo-French-Israeli joint attack on the Suez Canal zone in 1956. The Soviet Union used brute force to restore its domination of Hungary in 1956 and Czechoslovakia in 1968. There was of course the Soviet intervention in Afghanistan in 1979 which had a lot to do with the eventual collapse of the Soviet empire.

The establishment of the United Nations in 1945 and the evolution of international law since then have completely changed the rules of the game of the exercise of power by the introduction of the concept of legitimacy. It is universally recognised that there are only two scenarios of the legitimate use of force: pursuant to the Security Council authorisation or in the exercise of the right of self-defence. The latter has been severely circumscribed by the Charter which lays down that the right of self-defence can be exercised only in response to an attack by another state, thus rejecting the “pre-emptive” right of self-defence. The one case of unilateral use of force in the 21st century was the American intervention in Iraq in 2003 which the international community refused to recognise as legitimate since it did not have the imprimatur of Security Council approval nor was it accepted as having been in the exercise of the right of self-defence. United States/NATO intervention in Afghanistan, on the other hand, was sanctioned by the U.N.

Of the three constituent elements of “power” — military, economic and diplomatic — the economic is crucial. This is self-evident and does not need elaboration.

One important reason why the Soviet Union lost the Cold War was the mismatch between its bloated military and the inability of its economy to support and sustain it.

Is there a “superpower” in the contemporary world? The answer is clearly in the negative.

America has global reach, and its military is no doubt the strongest in the world. But this does not confer on it the capability to impose its will on others. To be fair to it, the U.S. does not ask others to recognise it as a superpower, though it does not protest when the rest of the world describes it as one.

 The Americans would rather prefer to be recognised as the “exceptional” power.

The capacity of its military as well as the will of its political leadership to deploy anywhere at any time without worrying about adverse political or diplomatic reaction remains, but it is severely hobbled by its increasing economic weakness.

To that extent, it is a global power. But it lacks in other attributes of power. The most embarrassing moment for American diplomacy was in March 2003 when it failed to persuade enough members of the Security Council, including some of its close allies, to support the “second resolution” on Iraq which would have legitimised its intervention in Iraq; only four countries promised support. More and more members in the U.N. vote in favour of the resolution criticising American sanctions against Cuba.

The U.S. has not had much success in getting countries such as India to fall in line with its Iran policy. Getting its nominee elected president of the World Bank has less to do with its diplomatic strength and more to do with the voting advantage that it and its allies enjoy as also to the lack of unity among the challengers for the job.

America is without doubt a super “soft” power. Its movies, television series, popular music, and, most of all, its espousal of democratic values have immense resonance among the youth of the world, especially in the Arab and Muslim world. But these do not translate into “power.”

About China


China is portrayed as a legitimate claimant for the title of global power. China's economy has been the principal engine of growth of the world economy but is now slowing down and facing the prospect of a reality bubble, political instability and huge corruption scandals. It is now not clear when, if ever, it will become the biggest economy in the world. Its military capability is nowhere close to America's. In R&D and labour productivity, it is way behind the U.S. China has increased its military profile, especially its navy. But the neighbours, while distrustful, are not afraid of China because of the American “pivot” or other factors. Much weaker countries, such as the Philippines, refuse to be intimidated by Chinese threats.

If the U.S. and China can be eliminated as candidates for “superpower” status, there is no need to consider any other state for the position.

India's case


Is India at least a “regional” power? The most conspicuous example of the exercise of power by India was the operation in 1971 in former East Pakistan. India's intervention was not authorised by the U.N.; India justified it on the ground of self-defence since Pakistan had earlier attacked several Indian Air Force bases as also on the one that Pakistan had in fact invaded India in the form of 10 million refugees. There is also the case of the intervention in the Seychelles in 1986, and one case of ill-advised military intervention, in Sri Lanka in the late 1980s which had disastrous consequences for India. There was talk of India sending a brigade to Iraq in 2003, but wiser counsel prevailed. As a general rule, Indian participation in military operations has been as a part of U.N.-mandated peace-keeping operations, with the exceptions mentioned.

The global powers of yesteryear became such for concrete reasons: control over sources of raw materials including oil and gas and protection of the interests of their corporations, e.g. the case of the United Fruit Company in Guatemala in the 1950s, an American company in which the then CIA director was a shareholder.

Why do some analysts in India feel enamoured of the prospect of India being called a global or a regional power? Is it because of the sense of self-importance or prestige? Will such a “title” give India a place at the high table in international diplomacy? Others sometimes use this adjective for us for one or both of these reasons: to flatter us — and we are the most flattery-prone people in the world — and/or to make us take foreign policy steps which would serve the objectives of those flattering us. Will the label of regional power help ameliorate the lives of the poor in our country, which is and should continue to be the guiding principle of our domestic as well as external policy? Further, while we have soft power of doubtful practical utility, we definitely are or have become or are becoming a super “soft state.” India's neighbours have the full measure of its will, or lack thereof, to use whatever hard power it has. One criterion of military power ought to be, not the unlimited capacity to pay for imports of hardware, but how much of it is the country able to manufacture domestically; India fares poorly in this respect. The possession of nuclear weapons does not change anything. Pakistan too has them. And, our nuclear weapons did not deter Pakistan from indulging in the Kargil adventure, but Pakistan's nuclear weapons apparently deterred us from crossing the Line of Control (LoC) at that time, and restrained us after 26/11. The boom years of India's economy seem to be over at least for the short term. Our forex reserves have ceased to grow and are likely to dwindle, with the rising energy bill and diminished exports. A reduction in interest rates might at some stage induce NRIs to start pulling out their deposits as it happened in 1990-91. A declining economy makes for a poor case for acceptance as a “power” of any kind.

In today's world, the concepts of super or global or even regional power do not make sense. We should not waste our time or energy over this non-issue. Fortunately, the Indian government does not seem to be much preoccupied about such recognition.
(Chinmaya R. Gharekhan, former Indian Ambassador to the United Nations, was until recently Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's Special Envoy for West Asia.)

1992 India, Pakistan drafts on Siachen

http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article3509868.ece
 

Text of draft Indian and Pakistani proposals on Siachen, November 1992:

Indian and Pakistani delegations headed by their respective Defence Secretaries met in New Delhi from November 2-6, 1992.

Indian draft (first) – 3rd Nov 1992

Consequent to discussions in the VI Round of Talks on the Siachen issue, both sides agreed to the following:

(i) Delineation of the Line of Control beyond NJ 9842: It was agreed that the immediate focus should be on restoring peace and tranquillity in the glacial region. Towards this end, without prejudice to the positions taken by either side in the earlier round of talks, both sides agreed that the LOC in this area shall be determined on a time bound basis.

(ii) Disengagement and Re-deployment: To secure enduring peace and tranquillity in this area both sides agreed to redeploy as follows:-

India: The Indian Army shall vacate their existing positions at …….. and…………. and redeploy at ……….

Pakistan: The Pak Army shall vacate their existing positions at ……… and ……… and redeploy at ……………

(iii) Zone of Disengagement: Consequent to disengagement from existing positions and redeployment to agreed positions, as noted in para (ii) above, both sides commit:

(a) that they shall not seek to re-occupy the positions vacated by them or to occupy the positions vacated by the other side or to occupy new positions across the alignment determined by the vacated positions.

(b) that they shall not undertake any military or mountaineering activity whatever in the Zone of Disengagement bounded as follows:

______________

______________

______________

(c) that if either side violates the Zone of Disengagement, the other side shall be free to respond through any means, including military.

(iv) Monitoring maintenance of peace in the Zone of Disengagement: Having committed themselves to maintain peace and tranquillity in the area comprising the Zone of Disengagement, both sides agree to the following monitoring measures to ensure against any violation of this zone:

(v) Implementation Schedule: In pursuance of their commitments in paras (i) to (iv) above, both sides agree to disengage and re-deploy as per the following schedule:

Pakistani Draft

Recognizing the need to bring to an end the enormous human and material losses being suffered by both countries in the Siachen area;

Noting that the Line of Control between the point NJ 9842 and the Karakoram Pass is yet to be delineated and that an understanding of the Siachen issue will eliminate an area of tension;

Considering that a settlement of the issue will constitute a major Confidence Building Measure;

Reiterating the desire to settle issues peacefully through negotiations in the letter and spirit of the Simla Agreement;

The two sides have agreed as follows:-

1) The area within the triangle Indira Koli - point NJ 9842 - Karakoram Pass will be vacated by the armed forces of the two sides.

2) The armed forces of the two sides will be re-deployed south of point NJ 9842 so as to conform with the Simla Agreement.

3) The modalities and time-frame of the re-deployment as well as the monitoring arrangements worked out by the military experts are annexed.

4) Neither side shall attempt to alter the status of the area within the triangle Indira Koli - point NJ 9842 - Karakoram Pass, pending delineation of the Line of Control.

5) A Joint Commission comprising experts from both sides will be set up in order to examine the question of delineation of the Line of Control. The Joint Commission shall commence work immediately after the completion of the re-deployment of forces and submit its report to the two governments within a period of six months thereafter.

Alternative para 1 & 2 (fall back position)

The armed forces of the two sides shall vacate areas and re-deploy as indicated in the annexure. The positions vacated would not for either side constitute a basis for a legal claim or justify a political or moral right to the area indicated. The delineation of the Line of Control from point NJ 9842 to the Karakoram Pass will form part of the comprehensive settlement to follow the re-deployment of troops.*

[* According to N.N. Vohra, then the Indian Defence Secretary, the Pakistani side dropped its reference to the Karakoram Pass]

Siachen was almost a done deal in 1992

Special Correspondent



Pakistan and India had reached a near agreement in 1992 on the Siachen dispute after Islamabad assented to recording the existing troop positions in an annex, but the deal was never operationalised because the Indian political leadership developed cold feet.

Pakistan Army Chief General Ashfaq Parvez Kayani said recently that it was time the two countries resolved the dispute. He said this during a visit to the region after an avalanche earlier this year on the Pakistani side killed more than 100 soldiers and civilians.

The text of the 1992 negotiating drafts — obtained and reproduced by The Hindu — shows just how close the two sides were to such a resolution two decades ago: the Pakistani delegation offered a proposal that met India's demand of recording existing ground positions before withdrawal of troops from a proposed zone of disengagement.

The talks that year, the sixth round both countries had held on the issue, took place in New Delhi from November 2-6, 1992.

Pakistan's proposal of indicating in an annexure the areas the armed forces of the two sides would vacate and redeploy to found immediate acceptance among Indian officials. The Indian delegation was led by N.N. Vohra, then the defence secretary. “We had finalized the text of an agreement at Hyderabad House by around 10 pm on the last day”, Mr. Vohra, who is now the Governor of Jammu and Kashmir, told The Hindu. “Signing was set for 10 am. But later that night, instructions were given to me not to go ahead the next day but to conclude matters in our next round of talks in Islamabad in January 1993”. “Of course, that day never came”, Mr. Vohra added. “That's the way these things go,” he said.

Narasimha Rao was Prime Minister at the time and the BJP's campaign against the Babri Masjid was in high gear. Siachen quickly receded from the government's list of priorities.

The 1949 ceasefire agreement delineated the Line of Control until point NJ9842, after which, it said, it would run “thence north to the glaciers”. In 1984, fearful of adverse Pakistani moves, Indian soldiers moved north and eventually occupied most of the highest points on the glaciers. The ‘Siachen conflict' was born.

The Indian side's proposal dated November 3, 1992 contained the following elements: delineation of the Line of Control north of NJ 9842; redeployment of troops on both sides to agreed positions, but after demarcating their existing positions; a zone of disengagement subsequent to the redeployment, with both sides committing that they would not seek to intrude into this zone; a monitoring mechanism to maintain the peace in the ZoD.

Pakistan's proposal was as follows: Both sides would vacate their troops from the triangular area between Indira Col in the west, Karakoram Pass in the east and NJ 9842; troops on both sides would withdraw to a point south of NJ 9842, to the pre-1972 Simla Agreement positions; neither side shall attempt to alter the status of the demilitarised triangle pending delineation of the LoC north of NJ 9842 by a joint commission.

The refusal to authenticate ground positions and the reference to Karakoram Pass — a point well to the east of NJ9842 and a red rag to the Indians — led to an impasse. As a way out, the Pakistani side, led by its defence secretary, offered the following compromise: “The armed forces of the two sides shall vacate areas and re-deploy as indicated in the annexure. The positions vacated would not for either side constitute a basis for legal claim or justify a political or moral right to the area indicated”.

Mr. Vohra said that by the time the talks concluded, an agreement had been reached which fully adhered to the Indian negotiating brief of troop positions being recorded one way or the other and that the Pakistani proposal that the LoC would run to the Karakoram Pass had been dropped. But the agreement was never signed.

In 2005, the two sides were once again said to be nearing agreement to demilitarize the region, but the deal fell through — Pakistan was no longer interested in demarcating the ground positions. After Pakistan's Kargil adventurism, such a demarcation became for the Indian side a non-negotiable, especially to the Indian Army, along with a mechanism to monitor any intrusions into a demilitarized zone in the Siachen region.
On Monday, the two countries will hold yet another round of talks on Siachen with no sign of a softening of attitudes on either side.

Tuesday, 5 June 2012

Most Australians against uranium sale to India: Survey

PTI


Melbourne, June 5: 

The Australian Government might have overturned a ban on uranium sale to India but a majority of people in the country still appear opposed to the idea of selling the mineral to New Delhi.

In a new survey, a majority of Australians were found to be against the recent Labor party decision of lifting the ban on uranium sale to India with 61 per cent opposing it.

“More than 60 per cent of Australians say they are against ‘Australia selling uranium to India’, with 39 per cent saying they are ‘strongly against’,” according to the eight annual Lowy Institute poll 2012.

In December 2011, the Australian Labor Party had overturned a ban on the sale of uranium to India following a heated national conference debate.

The results were published by the Lowy institute Poll after a nationally representative opinion survey of 1,005 Australian adults was done.

Key issues covered in the poll included uranium sale to India, relations with Fiji, the Bali bombings, climate change, the war in Afghanistan, migration, US Presidential elections, US military bases, and attitudes towards democracy and human rights.

The poll also included questions of migration, a perennially controversial topic.

It revealed that Australians recognised the need for short-term migration to address worker shortages with 62 per cent saying they were in favour of ‘the government allowing in extra workers from foreign countries’ when ‘there are shortages of workers in Australia and companies in Australia cannot find enough skilled workers’.

However, it was found that there was major opposition against large-scale foreign investment.

The poll also included several new questions about Australia’s image and engagement with the neighbourhood.

It was found that Australians believe it was important to be liked by neighbours, with 68 per cent saying it was ‘very important’ for ‘Australia to be seen in a positive light by people from countries in region’, with another 26 per cent saying it is ‘somewhat important’.

They also supported the government efforts to communicate with countries in the region.

Monday, 4 June 2012

India to Have an Exclusive Naval Satellite for Network-Centric Capabilities

 

Posted on: June 04, 2012
http://www.defencenow.com/news/709/india-to-have-an-exclusive-naval-satellite-for-network-centric-capabilities.html
The first dedicated military satellite for the Indian Armed Forces will become a reality in a month as the naval surveillance satellite gets readied for its launch. According to reports, the geostationary satellite will have over 1,000 nautical mile footprint over the Indian Ocean Region. Apparently, a new post has already been created called Assistant Chief of Naval Staff (ACNS) to supervise space-based military capabilities.
The military satellite will cover an area of over 1,000 nautical miles over the Indian Ocean Region (IOR) stretching from Africa's east coast up till Malacca Strait. The idea is to enable the naval force to network its warships, submarines and aircraft with operational centres ashore through high-speed data-links.
The pivotal role of the naval surveillance and communication satellite is to create synergy between its combat platforms and its land-based nodes through advanced communications and space systems. The intention is to turn the Indian Navy into a force geared towards network-centric operations for future challenges.
Meanwhile, Rear Admiral Kishan K Pandey has taken over as the new ACNS (communications, space and network-centric operations) of the Indian Navy. Besides laying down the infrastructure for network-centric operations, organisational changes have also been deliberated to carry out the new mode of naval operations and the ability to combat using space-based capabilities.
Last month, Defence Minister AK Antony had stated that India’s Navy and Air Force will have dedicated communication satellites between 2012 and 2014. While the naval satellite is almost ready to be launched, this will be followed by the army and air force communication satellite. The Indian Armed Forces have been dependent on "dual-use'' Indian satellites besides leasing the transponders on foreign ones for their navigation, communication, surveillance and reconnaissance purposes.

For the Indian Navy, the dedicated satellite will boost the maritime capabilities significantly at a time when the Indian Ocean region is greatly vulnerable to various threats including piracy as well as increasing Chinese presence in the region. It will enable the effective surveillance of that region to ensure that no foul play goes unnoticed and the sea lanes of communication is protected.
Defence Minister has also indicated that the tri-services defence communication network (DCN) is being progressed as per the defence procurement procedure. The DCN envisages a network of optical fiber cables, satellite, earth stations and transportable and portable satellite terminals with high security features.