Showing posts with label Indian Hegmonic Designs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indian Hegmonic Designs. Show all posts

Tuesday, 5 June 2012

To counter Pak, India to launch its own Urdu wiki

Anubhuti Vishnoi : New Delhi, Tue Jun 05 2012, 00:28 hrs
http://www.indianexpress.com/news/to-counter-pak-india-to-launch-its-own-urdu-wiki/957849/0

Come October, India will have its own Wikipedia in Urdu. The aim of the project is to not only provide authentic and comprehensive information in Urdu but to also counter Pakistan’s “propaganda” in the language.

The National Council for Promotion of Urdu language (NCPUL), which will launch the Urdu Wikipedia, has started work on the project.

India is concerned that its efforts and contribution to the Urdu language finds little mention internationally and particularity in the Urdu Wikipedia started from Pakistan. “Unfortunately, people from Pakistan are more in number and they keep their national interest ahead and mention India only where it is unavoidable. Creating our own “Urdu-Wiki” will enable us to tell our version of the story for promotion of Urdu language and literature,” NCPUL has stated, adding that Wikipedia’s Urdu version from Pakistan does not translate India’s effort in the field of Urdu language and literature and often editors erase India-centred posts or information

“Just like in Wikipedia, people will be able to provide and collect information about almost anything in the world. In Wikipedia, information contributed is vetted for authenticity by experts; we will do the same to ensure that information provided to the public is a rich database free of prejudice and misinformation. The NCPUL will attach its Urdu encyclopedia with the wikis,” Dr Khwaja Mohammed Ekramuddin, Director of NCPUL, said.

The NCPUL has also begun uploading digitalised Urdu texts on various subjects on its website and hopes to upload over 1,200 textbooks in Urdu in digital format.

Govt panel to develop new JEE software

Unfazed by objections to the new Common Entrance Exam proposed for admission to IITs and all other engineering institutes, the HRD Ministry on Monday started work on taking the proposal forward. A committee has been set up to develop a software that will take forward the new JEE plan for 2013, complete with systems for separate rankings for IITs and all other institutes, online formats for weightage and percentile formula, optical mark reader-based assessment of examination papers and so on.

Thursday, 10 May 2012

INS CHAKRA: A POTENTIAL THREAT TO INDIAN OCEAN STABILITY

Posted on 16. Apr, 2012 by Naveed Ahmed in Military Technology

http://www.opinion-maker.org/2012/04/ins-chakra-a-potential-threat-to-indian-ocean-stability/

By Naveed Ahmed
INS CHAKRA, a nuclear submarine, was formally inducted into the Indian Fleet at VISHAKAPATNAM, Headquarters of Eastern Naval Command, by the Indian defence minster Mr AK Antony on 4 April 2012.  This event could have taken place two years earlier but for the accident onboard the vessel during her sea trials in the Sea of Japan the entire project got delayed by at least two years.
How does induction of INS CHAKRA affect the naval balance in the Indian Ocean particularly when viewed in a regional perspective? Since INS CHAKRA is not carrying ballistic or cruise nuclear missiles onboard as such the parity with Pakistan in the strategic realm does not alter drastically, this is a point which needs to be correctly understood. However with the induction of the SLBM (Submarine Launched Ballistic Missile) carrying nuclear submarine, INS ARIHANT, likely to be inducted by end 2012, the strategic balance would definitely be altered. The presently inducted INS CHAKRA is an SSN submarine, whose strength lies in her ability to maintain almost unlimited sustained submerged covert presence in the Area of Interest either for reconnaissance or to undertake sea denial operations with the capacity to do high speeds of up to 30 knots, thanks to the unlimited power generated by its nuclear reactor.
Before examining other issues it is important to understand what constitutes a “Threat”. It comprises “Capability and Intent”.  “Capability” is permanent and is achieved over a long period of time whereas “Intent” is transient and can change overnight. Put simply “Capability” has a predominant role in defining the “Threat”. Induction of INS CHAKRA should be examined in the perspective of “capability”, as it has given India an unprecedented offensive capability generating a pronounced threat for all the stake holders in the region.
Let’s take a look at the affects of INS CHAKRA (SSN) on the Indian Ocean Region called IOR. This region extends from Australia in the East to South Africa in the West.  It links the world through most important straits including Straits of Malacca, Hormuz, Bab-al-Mandab and the Mozambique Channel. Leading economies of the world including China, Indian, Japan, and Australia are excessively dependant on these passages, also called “Choke Points”.  The ports of Indian Ocean handle about 30% of the world commerce. The trade flowing through Indian Ocean comprises 80% for extra-regional and 20% for intra-regional countries. Half of the world containerised traffic traverses through Indian Ocean. It is also home to the largest number of “Failed” or “Failing States” on the Foreign Policy Index. Three Nuclear powers (one potential) are poised perilously close to each other with simmering intra and extra regional conflicts making it the world’s most volatile region.
Starting from the East, lets examine how it affects Australia, which has the longest coastline of 36,000 km, second largest continental shelf and fourth largest EEZ  with economy totally dependant upon sea.  Potential presence of an SSN, capable of covertly monitoring and interfering with Australian SLOCs (Sea Lines of Communications) in a conflict situation will definitely make Australian maritime thinkers uncomfortable. Looking at South East Asia comprising some of the emerging economies like Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand and Indonesia, whose total economic growth is dependant on free flow of trade are already under the influence of growing Indian maritime military capability. The establishment of the Joint Command at Andaman & Nicobar Islands overlooking the Straits of Malacca has already squeezed vital strategic space from them. The enhanced threat in the form of INS CHAKRA would make these nations even more wary of Indian presence perilously close to their strategic interests.
On the other hand, South Asian countries are already suffering at the hands of an excessive Indian presence in Indian Ocean, almost all countries including Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka have/had some disputes with India in the maritime domain. This enhanced threat of covert presence of an SSN would add to the security concerns of these nations. GCC countries and Iran whose economies are totally dependant on free flow oil supplies to the world would definitely feel threatened as potential covert and sustained presence of an Indian naval platform right at the mouth of the Gulf in their strategic core area would alter their security calculus. Particularly, Iran would be more concerned due to growing Indo-US nexus and what role can Indian Navy potentially play in case of a conflict at sea.  
On the African continent, the countries neighbouring the Indian Ocean are already bogged down with their woes of almost failing economies and are constantly suffering at the hands of Somalian piracy. In the south, the strategic location of South Africa joining the Indian to the Pacific Ocean around the Cape of Good Hope is heavily dependant on maritime trade for its prosperity and well being. An enhanced presence of covert Indian platform close to its strategic areas generating potential threat, hitherto not possible, will be a cause of concern for South Africa.
The most affected of all  the nations is China whose economic security particularly her energy security is totally dependant on the  SLOCs passing through  Indian Ocean, therefore Chinese maritime interests  in the  Indian Ocean  are being directly threatened, more than yesterday. As a natural outcome China would adopt measures to protect its interests in the Indian Ocean resulting in increased presence of competing military powers for safeguarding their interests; thus possibly more militarisation and instability in the Indian Ocean. This therefore goes counter to the economic and strategic interests of the countries located in the Indian Ocean Region.
Similarly, France which is maintaining a permanent military presence in the Indian Ocean for safeguarding her overseas interests in La Reunion and Mauritius may not be totally at ease with the introduction  of an enhanced (additional SSN) military capability in the security calculus of Indian Ocean. Though the Indo-US nexus in the Indian Ocean has grown over the years however US would not allow an unbridled capability enhancement of the Indian maritime military capability particularly through the Russian conduit. In any case, the Indian SSN is a direct and potent military threat to the American Carrier Groups permanently stationed in Indian Ocean and Gulf, which US military planners can ill afford to ignore in the short and long term.
So what is to be done? The response to this exponentially growing military threat has to come from within the Indian Ocean Region countries particularly those, whose permanent interests are at stakes due to this unprecedented Indian naval expansion. The countries of Indian Ocean Region must unite their voices and exert pressure on India at all international forums through diplomatic and other means to curtail an un-justified and hegemonic Indian naval expansion jeopardising the regional and maritime strategic stability. Countries like Australia, South Africa, Malaysia, Singapore and Saudi Arabia must use their international stature and clout to curtail Indian hegemonic designs.  Response from countries like Pakistan, China and other directly affected countries including Iran would be but natural and morally justified, but the resultant affects would not serve the long term interests of Indian Ocean countries.

Saturday, 28 April 2012

Ranatunga was fired as SLC chief for opposing IPL: report

Agencies : Colombo, Sat Apr 28 2012, 13:15 hrs


Sri Lanka's World Cup-winning captain Arjuna Ranatunga's tenure as the head of the Sri Lanka Cricket (SLC) came to be short-lived because of his opposition to IPL, a report here has claimed.

'The Island', quoting SLC documents said Ranatunga was removed "after the BCCI applied pressure on the Sri Lankan government". Ranatunga was unavailable for comment on the matter.

The paper says an offer was made by the English Cricket Board (ECB) when Ranatunga was the head of SLC, for Sri Lanka to play a Test series in England, but the dates were clashing with the 2009 edition of the IPL.

Ranatunga's request for the players to return early from the IPL was staunchly resisted by the players. As there was no softening of the stance by Ranatunga, the BCCI summoned a Sri Lankan delegation to come over to Bangkok for talks.

During the meeting held in Bangkok in October 2008, the BCCI was represented by sacked IPL Commissioner Lalit Modi, current President N Srinivasan and the then secretary Niranjan Shah.

The newspaper claimed that the SLC delegation was warned of dire consequences unless they toed the BCCI line.

"The meeting that lasted for approximately two hours ended with the BCCI adopting a very aggressive stance, stating that the forthcoming Indian tours that have been indicated in the FTP up to 2012, stand unconfirmed at present and stated that they are not ready for any negotiations or to compromise with SLC, as long as SLC's present hostile approach," the report said.

"Mr Modi, together with Mr Srinivasan were very puzzled and shocked at the attitude of SLC towards the BCCI. The BCCI representatives had said that they had never had to contend with such an attitude with any committees which were previously handling the affairs of SLC and in particular, were very surprised and concerned about the comments made by Chairman, Arjuna Ranatunga, at different forums," it added.

Within a few weeks of the meeting, Ranatunga was removed as head of SLC by the Minister of Sports.

Ranatunga, who was a government parliamentarian at the time, switched over to opposition thereafter and still remains a strong critic of the IPL.

Friday, 16 March 2012

Misusing the Indus treaty

Asif H Kazi
Friday, July 01, 2011

Prof John Briscoe of Harvard University has identified India’s various unfair dealings with Pakistan in water-sharing. He has said that India must not interpret the treaty with the sole objective of punishing Pakistan.
There is growing feeling in Pakistan that while India is increasingly building dams on its western rivers, it is simultaneously engaged in activities aimed at stopping Pakistan, the lower riparian, from building storage dams on Pakistani rivers. In the case of its upper riparian neighbour, Nepal, India has even deployed heavy artillery to partially destroy dams which were being constructed by the Nepalese. India’s water strategy thus boils down to construction of more and more dams on cross-boundary rivers inside its own territory while obstructing dams in lower-riparian neighbours and destroying those in upper-riparian Nepal.


Pakistan’s farmlands have been deprived of the uses of the waters of three eastern rivers, Ravi, Beas and Sutlej. The flows of these rivers were allocated to India under the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty.
Authorities on the subject accept that when rivers and canals in Pakistan’s demarcated area were classified as Pakistan’s assets under the Partition Act, 1947, it meant only one thing: that these rivers and canals were to continue to receive water in the same way as before. Under the treaty, Pakistan was to enjoy the unrestricted use of the Indus, the Jhelum and the Chenab. However, exceptions were inserted as annexures which allowed India to develop and use certain specified quantities of water of the three western rivers as well.
Annexure E established Indian storage limits on the western rivers, which add up to 3.6 MAF (million acre feet). If Indian dams under rapid construction since then were to impound this storage water during high flood periods, as specifically defined in the treaty, Pakistan could live with the situation. However, India deliberately followed a pattern of filling water behind Baglihar Dam constructed on the Chenab River by impounding flows in the low-flow month of September,
a clear breach of the treaty which prescribes the filling period as being from June 21 to Aug 31.

Ironically, the 3.6 MAF of Indian storage share exceeds the sum total of the entire flow of the three remaining rivers entering Pakistan during the low-flow months of December, January and February. Thus the 3.6 MAF of storage creation, combined with its operational control over impounding and releases by India could mean completely drying up Pakistan’s three rivers for as long as three months. The consequences of this will be disastrous.

Obviously, the foregoing was not the intent of the Indus Waters Treaty. And it is precisely for this reason that Pakistan has been insisting that India adopt well-known dam design features, especially for the outlets, which can easily ensure that the reservoir operators would not be able to manipulate flows of the western rivers at their own sweet will. India is opposing this using as an excuse the need for the prolongation of the reservoirs’ lifespan through sediment flushing.
Prof Raymond Lafitte of Switzerland, the neutral expert on the Bhaglihar Dam dispute who gave his decision in favour of India, has acted as a pure professional engineer since he is trained to look at projects in the strictest sense of their operational efficacy and economic performance. Taking it for granted that the upper riparian would not resort to immoral or unethical practices, he failed to take into account the psyches and mindsets of the litigants in the context of their historic rivalry. Had he kept these factors in view, he might have concluded that, in the absence of spirit of cooperation, the only checks on an upper riparian to keep it from doing harm to the downstream country were constraints, as were proposed by Pakistan, in the shape of “minimum needed sizes of water outlets to be located at the highest levels” to prevent emptying and refilling of reservoirs at will.

In respect of India’s Kishenganga River (which takes the name of Neelum when it enters Pakistan), the treaty allows India to construct a hydroelectric project with storage within a certain limit, on a tributary of the Jhelum River. But it does not permit diversion of flows to either another tributary or to a storage such as Wullar Lake on the main Jhelum. Even when the permitted storage dam is constructed on the Kishenganga River, Paragraph 21(b) of Annex E makes it obligatory to deliver a quantity of water downstream of the hydropower station into the Kishenganga during any period of seven consecutive days, which shall not be less than the volume of water received in the river upstream of the project in that period. Such elaborate provisions have been embodied with the sole purpose of causing minimum changes in the natural river flow of these rivers to protect Pakistan’s interests.
In violation of these specific provisions, the proposed Kishenganga project violates the treaty in a most glaring way. Firstly, the hydroelectric plant is not located on the Kishenganga but way off the channel at the end of a long tunnel that discharges into another tributary. And, secondly, the recipient tributary ultimately outfalls upstream of the Wullar Lake, and this completely changes the patterns of the flows of both Kishenganga and Jhelum Rivers.

The position taken by the Pakistani government, as reported by Khalid Mustafa in The News of June 15, will not lead us anywhere. The news item says that whichever of the two countries completed their project first will be the winner in the eyes of the Court of Arbitration that recently visited Pakistan to verify, inter alia, our project status. Such a competitive race is a confusion being created which diverts attention from the real issue, that the treaty absolutely forbids India from undertaking their project.
As regards the Wullar Barrage Project, India again cannot undertake any construction under the treaty that would develop storage for whatever purpose, under Paragraphs 7 and 9 of Annexure E, on the Jhelum Main River. The very basic provision under the treaty is to restrain India from changing the river’s flow pattern (both quantity-wise and time-wise).

Several foreign experts have held the view that the highly sensitive and charged water issues between Pakistan and India have emerged out of the way the 1947 partition lines were drawn. A seemingly minor change, but one with far-reaching consequences, was introduced in the partition map, in violation of all principles laid down by the British government. It came about at the very last minute when, upon the insistence of the Indian leaders, the partition award turned over to India three vital districts that were originally allocated to Pakistan, with the sole objective of providing India with access to Kashmir. The three remaining western rivers on which Pakistan now relies upon all originate in or pass through Kashmir before entering Pakistan. In other words, India, after having obtained the waters of the three eastern rivers through Indus Waters Treaty, is now trying to take control of our three western rivers as well.
The writer is honorary vice-president of the International Commission on Large Dams (ICOLD)
http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=55416&Cat=9

Thursday, 15 March 2012

Bangladeshi Newspaper on Indian Hegemony

http://reformistani.wordpress.com/2010/06/22/bangladeshi-newspaper-on-indian-hegemony/

India wants hegemony over the region: says BD newspaper

A leading weekly newspaper of Bangladesh “The EkalerKatha” in its latest issue has strongly criticised India for its negative behaviour with neighbouring countries. The newspaper in its editorial said India extremely violates all norms of peaceful coexistence.In its June 17-23 issue, the weekly wrote, “Instead of coexistence with its neighbours with equal status and sovereignty India wants to forcibly realize submissive loyalty from its neigbours.”

India shows such attitude, as if, other sovereign countries of South Asian region will have to act on whatever India may dictate them to act and they will formulate their internal and external policies, even defence arrangements, according to India’s will and whims.”

The weekly says, India desires its neighbouring counties will obey and do whatever and whenever India asks them to do. “It means the expansionists of New Delhi will determine the extent of independence and sovereignty their neighbouring countries will enjoy,” it said.

Referring the recent comment of M K Narayanan, the weekly alleged, “India very recently bid to set such an example. India unjustifiably rebuked and scared Sri Lanka when she (Sri Lanka) expressed her desire to collect traditional, but effective, radars and other smaller equipments from Pakistan and China due to inability and failure of India-origin radars to detect air attacks of Tamil rebels.”

“Ignoring and reputing Sri Lanka’s sovereign and independent status, and violating all limits of shamelessness, M K Narayanan, India’s National Security Advisor, on May 13, 2007, thundered out like a so-called superpower declaring, “We are the big power in this region. Let us make it very clear. We strongly believe that whatever requirements the Sri Lankan government has, they should come to us. And we will give them what we think is necessary. We do not favour their going to China or Pakistan or any other country.

“M K Narayanan more nakedly said, we will not give such strong deterrents and arms to Sri Lanka that will ensure superiority of the Sri Lankan Armed forces over the Tamil guerrillas. It means, India wants to continue Sri Lanka’s war with the Tamils so that India can sell arms both to both the parties.” The weekly asked, “In what power and sense India expresses its intention to impose such disgraceful and shameful precondition on Sri Lanka that she will not be able to collect arms from other sources according to her own requirements and policy.”

“India’s such audacious threatening is also an awful warning to other sovereign and independent nations of the region. If the adventurous and audacious precondition that India designs to impose on Sri Lankais not responded befittingly with equal tone, India will tomorrow dare to impose such preconditions on other counties of the region as well,” the weekly warned.

Referring to the urgency of defence factor among the neighbouring countries of India, the weekly suggested, “To deter India’s aggressive attitude, all other countries of the region immediately should form a strong forum with strong military might. It is imperative to develop such strong and effective defence arrangement, so that India does not dare to extend its paw on any country of the region.”
Moreover, to make international community aware of the situation, the issue must be raised in the international forums uncovering India’s hegemonic designs that may irk unrest and violence, even war in the region, the weekly warned.
“No nation having minimum sense of prestige will tolerate or consume such insulting deliberation. So it is the responsibility of the international community to take initiative to bridle the expansionist paw of India and compel India to shun her aggressive and hegemonic design so that no evil shadow can overcast the region. No country in the region will accept the roar of so-called big power, named India,” the weekly opined.

The daily said, the concerned countries of the region have already made it clear that they will not accept such bully in the region. “Sri Lankan government itself officially conveyed the message to India and all concerned that Sri Lanka reserves the freedom to acquire necessary and suitable equipments from wherever this was available, particularly in view of the fact India was unable to meet Sri Lanka’s perceived needs.””The spokesman of Pakistan Foreign Ministry said, Pakistan would not accept the hegemonic tendencies from any country in the region and added, the matter primarily for Sri Lanka to decide,” the weekly quoted Pakistan’s reaction.

The weekly said, India’s statement virtually questions India’s attitude and policy to its neighbouring countries. “It is hoped good sense will develop in the mindset of Indian leadership. India for her own interest will shun its expansionist mentality and attitude and follow the policy of peaceful coexistence.”
“Otherwise India will have to compensate heavy price for its policy,” the weekly cautioned and added, “India should keep it in mind, the independent nations of this region will never accept Indian supremacy, i.e., slavery under any circumstances.”

http://www.app.com.pk/en/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=11073&Itemid=2′

Contributed by Isha Khan, who can be reached at bdmailer@gmail.com

Bangladesh submits totally to Indian hegemony

by Salah Uddin Shoaib Choudhury
November 23, 2011

I categorically hate falling in the line, where people are known as "anti India", while as a citizen of Bangladesh, I really cannot tolerate any action of New Delhi, which goes against the interest of my motherland. I always believe in keeping very friendly relations with India, but strongly oppose becoming a sycophant or unconditional slave of that country, though very unfortunately a large section of the politicians in Bangladesh, and of course those of the ruling party are desperately exhibiting their madly willingness of continuing as the champion lickers of feet of the Delhiwalas. Of course, people with such volatile tendencies are nothing more than enemies of the country.

When Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was in power during 1972-1975, New Delhi's policymakers very shrewdly took the written consent from Mujib in "testing the effectiveness" of the Farakka barrage, completely on a temporary basis for just 40 days. As anticipated by the political pundits and experts in Bangladesh, such "testing" of the Farakka barrage never ended and India continues to cause extreme sufferings to the people of Bangladesh as well as Poshchim Bangla, due to this demonic barrage. Bangladeshi rivers in particular are facing threats of getting dried, as a large number of rivers have already lost the minimum water level required for navigation. Farakka is the name of sorrow for millions of people in Bangladesh as well as in Poshchim Bangla. Many consider Farakka Barrage as New Delhi's heinous venture to punish the Bangla speaking millions as well as indigenous community both within Bangladesh and Poshchim Bangla.

Now, once again, the followers of Chanakya Doctrine have become frantically active in erecting one more barrage at Tipaimukh, which will not only add further sufferings to the people of Bangladesh, but will ultimately place Bangladesh into severe consequences, as the rivers will get quickly dried, while saline water from the Bay of Bengal will grab a large segment of the country, thus finally causing tremendous crisis of drinking water as well as completely destroying fertility of the agricultural lands.

Though Tipaimukh Barrage is going to cause severe natural and human catastrophe in Bangladesh, the foreign minister and the minister in charge of the water resources in Bangladesh are either behaving like duffers thus giving statements favorable to India, or even abetting such anti-Bangladesh actions of New Delhi, which definitely shows to us, how unpatriotic and power-greedy these elements are. It is a huge shame for Bangladesh that, a number of Bangladeshi ministers, including the foreign minister, is trying to act as advocate of Tipamukh Barrage, instead of putting any minimum reaction or protect with India as well as the international communities and the United Nations. Since independence, Bangladesh is for the first time is seeing a bunch of culprit politicians in power as well a large segment of equally culprit politicians in the opposition, who are not only failing to uphold the interest of Bangladesh, but are behaving like mere Indian agents, if not Indian slaves.

It is even rumored that Bangladeshi policymakers have secretly signed an agreement with India allowing New Delhi in erecting the Tipaimukh Barrage. I am not really willing to buy this rumor, as am not ready to consider our politicians as betrayers of that level, but of course, would like to surely investigate such serious allegations. If in real, any such secret agreement was at all signed, the signatories of such black documents will be labeled as "National Enemies" for such treacherous deeds. Whatever the political identities may be of any such politician, the heroic people of Bangladesh will ultimately stand up against such crime, if it has already been committed by signing the treaty.

Why the ruling elites of Bangladesh as well as a large segment of the civil society [shall I call them evil society] are maintaining tight-lip on this extremely important issue? Why self-exiled writers like Abdul Gaffar Chowdhury are mum on this issue? Is there any special reason behind their silence? Have they already pledged their "voice", conscious and even minimum level of self-respect to policymakers in India, just for the sake of continuing as New Delhi's favored and "blessed" political or intellectual concubines?

It is time for politicians and policymakers in New Delhi to immediately abandon the construction of the Tipaimukh Barrage. They should not feel that by managing few politicians and so-called civil society elites, it will be possibly to place such huge burden of acute sufferings on the people of Bangladesh. We Bangladeshis have fought against the repressive Pakistani forces in 1971, and if necessary, we shall begin another war against hegemonic forces of New Delhi if they will further proceed with such devastating project as Tipaimukh. It is clear that Tipaimukh barrage will actually put the entire Bangladesh into multiple sufferings and eventually will turn this beautiful country into a mere desert. Of course since independence, Bangladesh has tolerated number of Indian hegemony and repressive actions. But, this time the entire nation will wake up. Each and every pet-dogs of India inside Bangladesh will be thrown into the Bay of Bengal. This is the high-time for New Delhi to decide – if they want a friendly Bangladesh to live with dignity or India wants Bangladesh to wage a new war. And, of course, New Delhi should note, Bangladeshis never learnt to lose any war. Because, this is the land of braves and heroes!

India's food diplomacy: The other face of a friend

By Igor Siljanoski


It is very strange to note that India's food business with Bangladesh is directed not only to minimize her strategic importance, but also to undermine her sovereign and independent identity. To create famine India in mid September of 2007 banned exporting 5.5 lakh tons of rice to Bangladesh though the Bangladeshi importers paid the total price of the consignment. After the debacle cyclone of mid-December, when other friendly countries of Bangladesh like America, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, etc., stood beside Bangladesh with abundant assistance, Indian foreign minister Pronab Mukharjee went to Bangladesh at the last moment and declared in Dhaka that India would lift the ban of exporting rice that Bangladeshi importers purchased earlier. But during his talks with the Bangladeshi officials, Pronab Mukharjee and his entourages raised the issue of transit along with Chittagong port facilities and indirectly tagged preconditions with food export to Bangladesh.

It means Indians want to say, India will ease exporting rice and other edible goods to Bangladesh, if she provides transit to India. Due to geographical proximity and less transportation cost, Bangladesh prefers to import rice and other materials from India. India considers this policy of the Bangladeshi importers and government as weakness and dependence on India. India showing total disrespect to international norms and morality, uses Bangladesh's dependence on India for food and other consumers' goods as tool to squeeze the successive governments, including the current one. India tries to compel it to provide transit and other facilities, including Chittagong seaport facilities to India. India violating normal practice, imposes undesirable and unacceptable conditions on exporting rice and other edible goods, including pulse, onion, sugar etc., Bangladesh to create artificial scarcity of consumers' goods to 'discipline' Bangladesh government.

International observers who keep their eyes open on the subcontinental affairs say, India would not have withdrawn ban on exporting rice to Bangladesh if American Army did not land on Bangladesh soil to rescue and assist the cyclone-victims of 30 coastal districts of Southwestern Bangladesh. Indian policymakers considered it a threat to Indian hegemonic design in Bangladesh. (It seems strange to recall that India unconditionally invited American Navy, Air Force and Army to use Indian soil during US war on terror in Afghanistan. India will do the same if America ever tries to invade Iran, Pakistan or China, but its leaders could not tolerate presence of American Marines in Bangladesh territory.) Indian government not only used its Bangladeshi payrolls to raise hue and cry against the presence of American Army in Bangladesh territory, but also to please the people lifted its illegal embargo on exporting rice to Bangladesh that it (India) imposed earlier. Indian foreign minister Pronab Mukharjee visited Bangladesh after the withdrawal of American soldiers from Bangladesh and shamelessly tagged the transit issue to/with exporting food grains to Bangladesh. Such covert pressure and preconditions for transit in exchange of exporting food and other assistance dismayed the diplomatic circle in Dhaka.

Now let us see what type of transits and facilities India wants to get from Bangladesh.

*India placed fresh proposal to Bangladesh to provide her railway transit from Agartala to Chittagong port via Akhaura. Earlier India wanted to get railway facility through Jamuna Bridge. But due to cracks in the Jamuna Bridge and apprehending its (Jamuna Bridge) inability to bear heavy railway carriages and wagons, Bangladesh showed disinterest in providing railway transit from Kolkata to Chittagng Seaport. India without delay placed fresh proposal of reconstituting the Agartalata-Chittagong missing railway link. ADB (Asian Development Bank), primarily led by the Indians and heavily influenced by Indian government, also emphasises on implementing this proposal on an emergency basis. It also proposed lucrative investment proposal in this project. It was also proposed to construct another new bridge for railway alongside the Jamuna Bridge spending Tk. 10 thousand crores. India also proposed to solely finance to reconstruct Agartala-Akhaura rail-line, reconstruct the required infrastructures from Akhaura to Chittagong and construct double gauge rail-lines. India outwardly seeks such facilities to transport merchandises to and from Eastern Asia, what India terms as Northeast India, through Chittagong Seaport spending less money and time. Though such reconstruction will cost Tk. 2,000 to 2,500 crores, but once commissioned it will save only oil of worth Tk. 4 thousand crores every year. India has already completed the construction of rail line from Agartalta to Akhaura border.

*To go and come from Eastern Asia India also seeks road transit via Tamabil under Sylhet District of Bangladesh. Moreover, India has already sought road transit to ply lorry carrying merchandise from Benapole to Akhaura via Dhaka. India did not seek such facility earlier. India wants to carry goods from Akhaura to Agartala. The proposal of road transit was placed after reconstruction of Akhaura-Agartala missing rail-line. If construction of road from Akhaura to Agartala is delayed, India wants to carry the merchandise by rail.

*India proposes to ply four direct passenger buses every week from Kolkata to Chittagong via Dhaka and Kolkata to Gwauhati via Dhaka. India also asked to increase the number of buses that presently ply between Dhaka and Kolkata. Moreover, India sought the permission of landing 16 aeroplanes in Dhaka and Chittagong airports from different Indian aerodromes. India suggested Bangladesh to start similar number of air service to Indian airports. India deliberately placed such proposal, as Indian government knows it well that Bangladesh cannot afford such number of planes. So Indian proposal will only serve Indian interest, as India has sufficient aircrafts to ply along these routes. Once Air India gets chances to operate in these routes, Bangladesh Biman will lose its prospects to ply along these routes in future. Any prudent and judicious analysis will find Indian transit and other proposals as danger signal to Bangladesh. As India is not a landlocked country, so Bangladesh is not morally or internationally obliged to provide such transit to India. Now India to compel Bangladesh to concede to Indian demand tags its food business with transit.

Thanks to Indian policymakers and helmsmen of their statecraft to unfold the curtains of their real face once more by imposing indirect, but understandable preconditions in exchange of exporting food to Bangladesh, which are unprecedented and undesirable among the friendly nations of the contemporary world. The ulterior motive of their dubious diplomacy with Bangladesh is to delete the map of Bangladesh in course of time from the map of the globe. Under the cover of friendship and good neighbourly relations, Indian leaders passionately designs to implement their goal of binding Bangladesh under Indian cage.

Bangladesh government should not bend on the face of Indian pressure. Bangladesh should try to import rice and other necessaries from other sources, still it cannot sell out its sovereignty to India under the cover of transit. Bangladesh, however, can consider providing transit to India on the following conditions. India should:

*shun all of its hostile attitudes and activities to Bangladesh;

*stop unilateral blockade of waters of the international rivers and officially declares that it will not go ahead with the construction of Tipaimuk Dam and interlinking rivers project to divert the waters from India's eastern region to southern-western region that will virtually affect Bangladesh seriously;

*halt border aggression and create Indo-Bangladesh border a 'zone of peace';

*abandon anti-Bangladesh media propaganda in home and abroad and stop nursing tentacles and terrorists to carryout sabotage and destructive activities including campus and street violence, arson, impose strike and blockade, etc. inside Bangladesh;

The above preconditions mean that India must prove that she is no longer a hostile country to Bangladesh and only after fulfilling these conditions Bangladesh can provide transit to India if India also provides transit facilities to Bangladesh to connect her with Nepal, Bhutan, Pakistan and China (via Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh). Bangladesh should remain static to this demand. We cannot barter transit with food. Transit should be bartered for transit, but not with money or food, even with water.

Bangladesh government should not be afraid of India to remain in power. Government should remember that if it enjoys the popular support of 160 million Bangladeshis, all types of Indian hegemonic design, pressure, threat or embargo will be of no use. The incumbent government should not concede to any Indian pressure, which will ultimately brand it as pro-India tool. On the other hand, if they bow down to Indian pressure for their any hidden interest, history will never pardon them, they will be treated as Indian agents and traitors.

Igor Siljanoski is a policy professional working and residing in Windsor, Ontario, Canada. His previous experience was in the public sector as an economist, economic development consultant and business and financial planner. Igor is lecturing macroeconomics at the St.Clair College of applied arts and science in Windsor, Ontario. Igor holds Masters Degree in Political Science and Honours Bachelor of Arts in International Relations from the University of Windsor, Canada. Email: igor.siljanoski@gmail.com

Sunday, 4 March 2012

India's quiet sea power



BANGALORE - India's new listening post in Madagascar has reportedly begun operations. Under construction for more than a year, the monitoring station will provide India with electronic eyes and ears in the southwestern Indian Ocean.

Located in northern Madagascar, the monitoring station "was quietly made operational" in early July, according to a report in The Indian Express. It will be linked with similar facilities in Kochi and Mumbai "to gather intelligence on foreign navies operating in the region", the report said. Mumbai and Kochi, which are on India's west coast, are headquarters of the Indian Navy's Western and Southern Commands, respectively.

Madagascar, a large island off Africa's east coast, is among a growing number of Africa's Indian Ocean shores with which India is building naval and other ties. The Indian Navy took charge of Mozambique's sea security during the African Union summit there in 2003 and during the World Economic Forum summit the following year.

To Madagascar's east lies Mauritius. In 1974, India laid the foundation of its naval security cooperation with Mauritius with the gift of the Indian Naval Ship (INS) Amar. India later provided Mauritius with an interceptor patrol boat, INS Observer, in 2001 and a Dornier Do 228 maritime surveillance aircraft in 2004. The Indian Navy has patrolled waters off Mauritius a few times.

Media reports last year spoke of a possible larger profile for India in Mauritius. According to reports, Mauritius offered its Agalega Islands to India on a long-term lease ostensibly for development as tourist destinations. The Agalega Islands are 1,100 kilometers from Mauritius, 3,000km from India and 1,800km from the US base at Diego Garcia.

Both India and Mauritius quickly denied the lease report - the leasing of a predominantly Creole island to India would be a touchy issue in a country with a delicate ethnic balance between the francophone Creoles and the Indo-Mauritians. However, according to the Indian Express report, "India is looking at developing another monitoring facility at an atoll it has leased from Mauritius [Agalega] in the near future." The report said that while the government is silent on the issue, "sources say some forward movement has recently been made on the project".

Across the channel to Madagascar's west lies Mozambique. Last year, India signed a memorandum of understanding with Mozambique that envisaged maritime patrolling of the waters off the latter's coast, supplying military equipment, training personnel, and transferring technical know-how in assembling and repairing military vehicles, aircraft and ships.

India's long-standing ties with Seychelles were further strengthened in 2005 when Delhi gave the latter's coast guard a fast-attack vessel, INS Tarmugli. India has given a few helicopters to Seychelles over the years and Indian naval ships routinely visit the archipelago.

India's naval foray into the southwestern Indian Ocean has gone by largely unnoticed. In contrast, its naval presence and activity near the Malacca Strait to its east and the Gulf of Oman to its west has been widely reported. The Indian Navy has been conducting exercises with the Republic of Singapore Navy for more than a decade, with the Indonesian Navy since 2004, and with the Royal Thai Navy since last August. Next month, the navies of five countries - India, Singapore, the United States, Japan and Australia - will participate in a huge naval exercise in the Bay of Bengal. To its west, India has been holding joint naval exercises in the Gulf of Oman, the Gulf of Aden and the Arabian Sea with such countries as Oman, Iran and France.

India's naval profile in the southwestern Indian Ocean is smaller but growing quietly. Naval exercises with South Africa - the only medium naval power in Africa - and Brazil are expected to take place next year.

Indian Navy officers say that India's gifts of patrol boats and other equipment to countries in its immediate and distant neighborhood are to "help them identify and isolate more effectively fast-moving surface craft that may be carrying terrorists, gun-runners or smugglers. By providing these countries with better equipment, India is not only helping them secure themselves but also hoping that this will halt the flow of arms, ammunition and contraband into India."

There is the problem of piracy, too, in the waters off Africa that has affected India's trade. To the north of Madagascar lies Somalia, whose coastline has been identified by the International Maritime Bureau (IMB) as the area with the highest piracy risk in the world. According to the latest IMB report, there were 15 reported attacks on vessels in or near Somalia's waters in the first seven months this year, compared with 10 incidents during all of last year. An Indian merchant ship was seized by Somali pirates this May and held for a month.

For India, monitoring the waters off Africa's east coast is an essential part of its effort to secure sea lanes of communication in the Indian Ocean. Most of India's trade is by sea - nearly 89% of India's oil imports arrive by sea. These sea lanes are thus lifelines for the Indian economy and any disruption can have disastrous consequences for its economic and energy security.

India has been acting to secure sea lanes in the Indian Ocean, and the monitoring station in Madagascar is part of this larger naval and maritime strategy.

India is reaching out far into the Indian Ocean, way beyond its shores, as it sees this ocean as its domain. In an article published last year in the Naval War College Review, Donald L Berlin, professor at the Asia-Pacific Center for Security Studies in Honolulu and an expert on Indian Ocean strategic issues, wrote:

New Delhi regards the Indian Ocean as its back yard and deems it both natural and desirable that India function as, eventually, the leader and the predominant influence in this region - the world's only region and ocean named after a single state. This is what the United States set out to do in North America and the Western Hemisphere at an early stage in America's "rise to power". American foreign policy throughout the 19th century had one overarching goal: achieving hegemony in the Western Hemisphere.

Similarly, in the expansive view of many Indians, India's security perimeter should extend from the Strait of Malacca to the Strait of Hormuz and from the coast of Africa to the western shores of Australia. For some Indians, the emphasis is on the northern Indian Ocean, but for others the realm includes even the "Indian Ocean" coast of Antarctica.

Of major concern to India is China's steady influence in the Indian Ocean through its naval and other ties with India's neighbors, including Myanmar, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Pakistan. China has a major role in the Gwadar port in Pakistan at the mouth of the strategic Persian Gulf, about 400km from the Strait of Hormuz, a major conduit for global oil supplies.

Concern mounted in India in January when Chinese President Hu Jintao rounded off his eight-nation trip to Africa with a stop at Seychelles. It was to preempt a Chinese offer of naval assistance to Seychelles that India quickly gave INS Tarmugli to the Seychelles Coast Guard. Hu's visit - the first by a Chinese president to an island state in the southwestern Indian Ocean - underscored the looming challenge that China poses to India's influence in this region.

Raja Mohan, an Indian strategic-affairs expert, pointed out: "No one doubts India's desire to retain its foothold in these geopolitically crucial island states. But question marks remain on whether India has a strategy to cope [with] China's dramatic entry into the western Indian Ocean."

Indian Navy eyes Maldives

Indian Navy eyes Maldives - Counter to China’s ‘string of pearls’ plan


SUJAN DUTTA

New Delhi, Aug. 19: A tiny pearl of an island with a former World War II airbase in the Maldives is now the Indian Navy’s strategic object of desire.
Defence minister A.K. Antony’s visit to the Maldives with a high-level team for three days starting tomorrow will not name Gan, or Addu Atoll, where the coral island is located, just south of the equator.

But the navy wants a permanent presence in Gan for its surveillance aircraft, along with a presence of its ships and other aircraft in both Male, the capital of the Maldives, and Hanimadhoo, in the Haa Dhalu Atoll in the island country’s north, which is barely 20 nautical miles (37km) south of the Indian islands of Minicoy.

As India and China seek to expand their influence in the Indian Ocean region, territories barely marked on maps are popping up like beacons in the vast blue. Gan, in Addu Atoll, is the latest.

The Indian delegation is likely to propose building or renovating a hospital in the Maldives. Antony is accompanied by, among others, the director general of the Armed Forces Medical Services, Lieutenant General N.K. Parmar.

Navy officials agreed that Gan was of “great strategic importance” but were reluctant to describe their idea of a presence there as a “naval base”.

“It is important for us to station assets there. That does not mean taking it over. In fact, we have flown our aircraft from there. We want to station there now,” a senior official said.
India does not expect this to happen overnight. Antony is expected to begin an essay in persuasion, with goodies thrown in, and a review of mutual benefits at the discussions tomorrow.

This is how New Delhi hopes to sell the idea of a listening post in Gan, or Addu, to Male: You have concerns over your environmentally fragile exclusive economic zone and about patrolling and policing your far-flung islands, some of which are uninhabited. And we, the Indian Navy, are the “regional stabilising force” in the Indian Ocean.

Indian officials will make the point that the navy is, in any case, patrolling waters a mere 15 nautical miles from the Maldives.

The group of coral islands that make up the Maldives is about 600km from its north to south.
The Maldives does not have a navy. India will offer to patrol and keep an eye over its territories. For India, the benefit: it gets a listening post that will monitor movement of Chinese vessels as they sail to and from Africa. More than 60 per cent of Chinese oil imports are assessed to be sourced from Africa.

New Delhi’s military establishment is wary of China’s “string of pearls” strategy — the phrase used to describe the pockets of influence that Beijing wants to dot around India, starting with the port of Gwadar in Pakistan to the port of Hambantota, which China is developing in the southern tip of Sri Lanka, to Myanmarese and Bangladeshi ports in the Bay of Bengal.

India has over the years tried to develop military bases overseas without great success. Its first has been in Farkhor and Ayni. Ayni is about 10km south of Dushanbe, the capital of Tajikistan, which borders Afghanistan on its north. Pakistan and China find an Indian military presence in Farkhor, also in Tajikistan, threatening.

An Indian military presence in Gan — formerly the RAF Gan, so named after the British navy built it for its fleet air arm and then handed it over to the Royal Air Force — means an extension of reach for its navy. The Indian Navy sees its area of responsibility in the ocean covering the space between the Persian Gulf and the Malacca Straits.

Antony will also be accompanied by defence secretary Pradeep Kumar, director-general of the coast guard, Vice Admiral Anil Chopra, and deputy chief of navy staff, Vice Admiral D.K. Joshi.

Antony is scheduled to meet Maldives’ President Mohammed Nasheed shortly after landing. In the back-to-back meetings tomorrow, the delegation will talk to officials and ministers in Male and to the Maldives National Defence Force.

A defence ministry release today said Antony “will also attend the closing session of the India-Maldives Friendship function besides paying a visit to the Indira Gandhi Memorial Hospital, the most visible symbol of Indo-Maldives cooperation and friendship.”

India was the first to recognise Maldives after its independence in 1965. In 1988 India’s military launched Operation Cactus to foil a coup attempt in Male. In April 2006, India gifted a fast-attack craft, the INS Tillanchang, to the Maldives.