Showing posts with label War. Show all posts
Showing posts with label War. Show all posts

Tuesday, 3 April 2012

Cristina Kirchner declassifies report into Argentine military failings during Falklands War

Argentine president Cristina Kirchner has finally declassified a scathing review of the mistakes made by Argentina's military junta in going to war with Britain in 1982 trying to recover the Falkland Islands.


24 Mar 2012




The Rattenbach Report is so critical of Argentina's military leadership that the last dictator ordered it kept secret for 50 years.

By making it public, Mrs Kirchner said she hopes to show Argentina "will always be on the side of peace." She also said very little of the report needed to remain classified - just the names of an active Argentine intelligence agent and an islander who collaborated with Argentine forces.

Mrs Kirchner has sought to blame the 1976-1983 dictatorship and not the Argentine people for the failed war, while at the same time using non-military means in hopes of squeezing Britain into negotiating the islands' sovereignty. Argentina say Britain has illegally occupied what they call the Islas Malvinas since 1833.

A version of the report was leaked decades ago, and its conclusions are not a surprise: the junta planned for an easy occupation, gambling the US would support them and Britain would simply let the islands fall into Argentine hands.

Then Argentina's ill-equipped army had to scramble into a war footing after Margaret Thatcher sent a task force 8,000 miles into the South Atlantic to take the islands back.

The report confirms Argentine soldiers were sent from the subtropics into winter conditions without proper clothing, food or weapons, and were treated as cannon fodder by their own officers - pushed into battle without having had basic training in weaponry and combat.

"Troops weren't adapted or equipped to handle the weather or the living conditions," and yet they had to face "a highly equipped and trained enemy," the report concluded.

"Military commanders encouraged the preconceived notion that there would be no armed conflict, and that the situation would be resolved diplomatically, which affected the morale of the forces and their readiness for combat."

The Argentine occupation began on April 2, 1982, and ended 74 days later with British troops crushing the ill-prepared Argentines, at the cost of more than 900 lives.

Tensions have increased between Buenos Aires and London ahead of the 30th anniversary. Argentina says Britain has violated treaties and United Nations resolutions by militarizing the South Atlantic. It has sought to isolate Britain and the islands by barring trade, ships and planes from adjacent Argentine territory, and has gained diplomatic support across Latin America.

Retired Colonel Augusto Rattenbach, whose father, General Benjamin Rattenbach, co-authored the report, said releasing it is important for moral as well as historical reasons.

War, he said, "is not the right way to solve these problems - diplomacy is."

Falkland Islands: UK denies sending nuclear-armed submarine to South Atlantic

27 Mar 2012




Nick Clegg rubbished claims by the South American country that Trident nuclear missiles were being carried on board a Royal Navy submarine deployed to the region.

The Deputy Prime Minister dismissed the ''baseless insinuations'' in a clash with Hector Timerman, the Argentine foreign minister, at the international Nuclear Security Summit in Seoul, South Korea.

The latest row between the country's erupted as British officials braced for intensifying diplomatic pressure from Buenos Aires in the run-up to the 30th anniversary of the Falklands War.

Mr Timerman claimed last month that the UK had despatched a nuclear-powered but conventionally-armed Trafalgar class submarine to the region.

The Ministry of Defence refused to confirm or deny the deployment at the time.

But Mr Timerman told the United Nations that Britain had in fact sent a nuclear-armed Vanguard class submarine in violation of the Treaty of Tlatelolco, which guarantees Latin America as a nuclear weapons-free zone.

In the face of denials issued through diplomats, Mr Timerman insisted that a Vanguard-class submarine, which carries Trident nuclear missiles, was operating in the region.

He produced maps and photographs to back up his claims, stating that the nuclear submarine posed a threat to regional security.

"Argentina has information that within the framework of the recent British deployment in the Malvinas Islands they sent a nuclear submarine ... to transport nuclear weapons to the South Atlantic," Mr Timerman told a press conference in New York.

"Thus far the UK refuses to say whether it is true or not. Are there nuclear weapons or are there not?

"The information Argentina has is that there are these nuclear weapons.

Despite British denials, officials said Mr Timerman had repeated the allegation at Tuesday's meeting in Seoul.

He had referred to an ''extra-regional power'' which had deployed a submarine ''capable of carrying nuclear weapons'' in the South Atlantic.

But Mr Clegg, who is leading the British delegation at the summit, strongly rejected the claim.

''These are unfounded, baseless insinuations,'' he said.

''As I'm sure our colleague from Argentina knows, the United Kingdom ratified the protocols to the treaty in 1969 ... which guarantees a nuclear weapons-free zone covering Latin America and the Caribbean.

''We have respected those obligations since 1969 and we will continue to do so.''  

In comments released by Downing Street, Britain's ambassador to the UN Sir Mark Lyall Grant said: "On the nuclear issue, nothing has changed with regards to the British defence posture in the region.

"Since 1982, we have had to increase our defence posture. We do not discuss the whereabouts of nuclear weapons around the world.

"We are not looking to start a war of words. We will defend our position and we will defend it robustly and we have no intention of increasing our rhetoric on this matter."

A spokesman for the Argentine foreign minister has not commented on Mr Clegg's comments.

Friday, 16 March 2012

50 years on, Algeria war resonates in French election

http://www.dawn.com/2012/03/15/50-years-on-algeria-war-resonates-in-french-election.html

PARIS, March 14: Fifty years after losing the Algerian war, France is still suffering fallout from a conflict that shamed its armed forces and fuels bitter political rows even in its latest election battle.

Though French officials are keen to play down the 50th anniversary on March 18 of the ceasefire that ended the conflict, the war’s legacy has reared its head in the run-up to France’s April-May two-round presidential vote.

Hoping to make gains on the right, President Nicolas Sarkozy has reached out to the community of European-descended Algerians, known as “pieds noirs”, who fled the country after the war and still make up a powerful voting bloc.

And on the fringes of the campaign, Left Front candidate Jean-Luc Melenchon has accused far-right National Front founder Jean-Marie Le Pen, whose daughter Marine is running third in the polls, of having “blood up to his elbows” for having served as an intelligence officer during the war.

The anniversary will mark the signing of accords in 1962 with Algeria’s National Liberation Front (FLN) that ended a more than seven-year conflict that saw Algerian nationalists rise up against and eventually defeat their French colonial rulers.

The conflict, which left at least 400,000 dead, saw brutal atrocities on both sides, but French forces have particularly been criticised for the systematic use of torture against Algerian fighters and civilians.

With these bitter memories – amid concerns about present-day relations with Algerian authorities – French officials say there will be no official ceremonies to mark the anniversary.

“We must avoid fanning the flames,” a French diplomat said on condition of anonymity.

“Our concern is to avoid any outbursts in a very volatile context,” the diplomat said, noting that as well as the French presidential election, Algeria will be heading to the polls for a legislative vote on May 10.

But that hasn’t stopped the war from playing a role in the French vote.

In a speech earlier this month, Sarkozy spoke at length of the “nightmare” endured by pieds noirs when they were forced to choose between “the suitcase or the coffin.” The group and their descendants account for an estimated 3.2 million voters who have traditionally backed either the right or far-right.

Sarkozy, who is trailing Socialist candidate Francois Hollande in the polls, reached out also to voters among the so-called “harkis” – the up to 200,000 Algerians who fought for the French during the war.

Nearly half of them fled to France after the conflict, but the government initially refused to recognise their right to stay in the country and many ended up in internment camps.

Sarkozy has denounced the “injustice” of their fate and their “abandonment” by French authorities.

The war also came to the fore in a vicious exchange between Melenchon and Le Pen after Marine Le Pen refused to hold a televised debate with the far-left candidate.

After Le Pen senior accused the Communists, part of the coalition backing the Left Front candidate, of having blood on their hands, Melenchon shot back that Le Pen’s service in Algeria had left him with “blood up to his elbows … the blood of a torturer”.

Historians said that even after 50 years there is a hunger in France to discuss the war – a seminal event in French history that for many still resonates.

“At the state level the commemoration may be silent, but on the other hand there is a big demand for historical memory on the part of society, from young generations who want to know what happened,” historian Benjamin Stora said.

“While it was France that lost the war in Algeria, paradoxically it is in France where it is much talked about, while in Algeria it is little talked about. Maybe that will come,” he said.-AFP

Algeria conflict shapes US military strategy

http://www.dawn.com/2012/03/16/algeria-conflict-shapes-us-military-strategy.html

WASHINGTON: The French military experience in Algeria 50 years ago has left an indelible mark on a new generation of US officers, who have tried to apply the lessons of the conflict to the fight against insurgents in Afghanistan and Iraq.

As France marks the 50th anniversary of a war that remains a bitter memory, the strategy and tactics employed by French forces have enjoyed a revival inside the US military.

After quickly toppling regimes in Baghdad and Kabul, American commanders were caught off guard by virulent insurgencies in both countries that posed a challenge to a force trained only for conventional combat.

“It is not unfair to say that in 2003, most Army officers knew more about the US civil war than they did about counterinsurgency,” John Nagl, a retired colonel who served in Iraq, wrote in the foreword to the army’s manual on irregular warfare.Facing a politically savvy adversary seeking to exploit resentment of foreign troops, US military officers saw parallels in the Algerian war.

In August 2003, the Pentagon organised the showing of the 1966 film “The Battle of Algiers,” the Gillo Pontecorvo movie that recounts operations in the Casbah, including the torture of guerrillas by the French.

“How to win a battle against terrorism and lose the war of ideas. Children shoot soldiers at point-blank range. Women plant bombs in cafes. Soon the entire Arab population builds to a mad fervour. Sound familiar?” read a Pentagon flyer for the screening.

Encouraged by senior officers such as General David Petraeus, who served as commander in Iraq and Afghanistan before leading the CIA, the French counter-insurgency doctrine honed in Algeria was gradually rediscovered and promoted.

Petraeus oversaw the writing of a new field manual for counter-insurgency in 2006 that drew heavily on the Algeria era and one French strategist in particular, Lieutenant Colonel David Galula, author of “Counterinsurgency:

Theory and Practice.”Galula’s book, published first in the United States in 1964, enjoys prominent references in field manual 3-24 and is cited as a “classic” in the bibliography.

“Of the many books that were influential in the writing of Field Manual 3-24, perhaps none was as important as David Galula’s ‘Counterinsurgency Warfare: Theory and Practice,’” Nagl wrote.

Reflecting Galula’s ideas, American troops conducted sweeps through urban areas, sought to cut off insurgents from the population, trained local forces and pored over intelligence to identify the leaders and motivations of the insurgency.

US strategists also frequently cite “Modern Warfare” by Colonel Roger Trinquier, a veteran of the Algeria war who was critical of his own army’s slow adaptation to new tactics.

Trinquier, however, openly advocated torture as a means of extracting vital information from guerrillas. The US counter-insurgency manual explicitly prohibits abusing prisoners, saying the practice plays into the hands of insurgents and undermines America’s “moral legitimacy”.

Both Trinquier and Galula “captured with considerable nuance the conduct of counter-insurgency operations of that day, and a good bit of the way those operations were conducted remains instructive and relevant,” Petraeus wrote in an email to AFP.

As head of the Command and General Staff College, Petraeus ordered the purchase of the English translation of Galula’s work and had a copy issued to every one of the more than 1,200 students at the college, he said.

Petraeus and other soldiers have found kindred spirits among their French counterparts in the Algerian war, at least as they are portrayed by French writer and journalist Jean Larteguy in his 1960 novel “The Centurions”.-AFP

Sunday, 26 February 2012

Tanker War in Persian Gulf

1984: 'Tanker War' in Persian Gulf

The Tanker War started when Iraq attacked Iranian tankers and the oil terminal at Kharg Island in early 1984. Iran struck back by attacking tankers carrying Iraqi oil from Kuwait and then any tanker of the Persian Gulf states supporting Iraq. Both nations attacked oil tankers and merchant ships, including those of neutral nations, in an effort to deprive the opponent of trade. Iraq declared that all ships going to or from Iranian ports in the northern zone of the Persian Gulf were subject to attack. Saddam's hope in beginning the "tanker war" was that in response to Iraqi attacks against its shipping, the Iranians might do something extreme in retaliation such as closing the Strait of Hormuz to all shipping. The United States had threatened several times to go to war if the Strait of Hormuz was closed. For this reason, the Iranians refused to rise to the bait, and so limited their attacks in retaliation to Iraqi shipping. Iran attacked tankers carrying Iraqi oil from Kuwait and then any tanker of the Persian Gulf states supporting Iraq. The air and small boat attacks did very little damage to Persian Gulf state economies and Iran just moved its shipping port to Larak Island in the strait of Hormuz.

Iraq used its air power to enforce its threats, primarily helicopters, F-1 Mirage and MiG-23 fighters armed with Exocet anti-ship missiles. After repeated Iraqi attacks on Iran's main exporting facility on Khark Island, Iran attacked a Kuwaiti tanker near Bahrain on 13 May 1984, and a Saudi tanker in Saudi waters on 16 May. Attacks on ships of noncombatant nations in the Persian Gulf sharply increased thereafter, and this phase of the Iraq-Iran war was dubbed the "Tanker War." The Iranian attacks against Saudi shipping led to Saudi F-15s shooting down an Iranian aircraft on 5 June 1984.
The Iranian Navy imposed a naval blockade of Iraq, using its British-built frigates to stop and inspect any ships thought to be trading with Iraq. They operated with virtual impunity, as Iraqi pilots had little training in hitting naval targets. Some Iranian warships attacked tankers with ship-to-ship missiles, while others used their radars to guide land-based anti-ship missiles to their targets.

Though the "tanker war" alarmed the United States, it was not followed up with any significant American action until 1987. After several Iranian attacks on Kuwaiti shipping, the United States Navy started in March 1987 to escort Kuwaiti tankers provided that they flew the American flag. In April 1987, the Soviet Navy also started escorting Kuwaiti tankers. A US Navy ship, the USS Stark, was struck on 17 May 1987 by two Exocet antiship missiles fired from an Iraqi F-1 Mirage plane. The Iraqi fighter fired the Exocet missiles at about the time the fighter was given a routine radio warning by the Stark. The frigate did not detect the missiles with radar and warning was given by the lookout only moments before the missiles struck. The missiles hit the ship and one exploded in crew quarters, killing 37 sailors and wounding 21.

Attacks on shipping

Lloyd's of London, a British insurance market, estimated that the Tanker War damaged 546 commercial vessels and killed about 430 civilian sailors. The largest portion of the attacks were directed by Iran against Kuwaiti vessels, and on 1 November 1986, Kuwait formally petitioned foreign powers to protect its shipping. The Soviet Union agreed to charter tankers starting in 1987, and the United States offered to provide protection for tankers flying the U.S. flag on 7 March 1987 (Operation Earnest Will and Operation Prime Chance). During the course of the war Iran attacked two Soviet Navy ships which were protecting Kuwaiti tankers. One of the ships which was damaged as a result of an attack during the war was the Seawise Giant carrying Iranian crude which was struck by Iraqi Exocet missiles, resulting in the damage of the largest ship ever built in history.